I don't mind you discussing both trips here and I love all the pictures of Aria. She is adorable!
Ok, thank you!
I have done the carriage ride and the sleigh ride through Fort Wilderness. While I adored both, I would go with the sleigh ride. They only do them for about a month and a half where the carriage rides are done all year. You can do one of those on a future trip no matter when you go. I would schedule the carriage ride for as late as possible and the sleigh ride for as early as possible. It is cool starting off with some light. Pictures come out better when it is not too dark. On the carriage ride, you will not likely take many (or any) photos.
Boatwrights is the only restaurant on your list I have not tried, so I cannot help you with that. I can say that the Garden Grill was our least favorite for food of the others on your list. Xander slept through the whole meal (except for a brief moment when Chip accidentally woke him up), and we still had to pay for him since it was family style. Luckily, we were on deluxe dining that trip, so it was okay.
I think it is better to keep pre-trip reports combined. It just seems easier. When you get back from the first trip, everyone will know you've switched over to the second.
I like real life updates and love looking at pictures of cute kids.
I think Aria would make an adorable Boo. It may be difficult to get everything you need, but you are getting an early start. You should go for it. There is no way I would ever be able to make something like that, so I would try to order or find it. Jack Sparrow is a great Disney costume for a pirate lover. Hopefully, he does it. Now, you need to think of what you want to be and start shopping. It should be a lot of fun.
I laughed at the kid falling over from the ARRGGHHH. Oh man.
LOL ok thanks for the tips. I'll definitely have to think about the sleigh rides, it might be asking a lot to fit them in at all, but I'll talk to DH. He seemed interested in the POR one and we both LOVE Christmas so he might like to go for that. It'd really work out if the Be Our Guest restaurant opens up, then we could hope over to FW before Wishes.
I mentioned the costumes to DH and his eyes lit up and he said "OOoh I can be Captain Jack Sparrow" LOL as if it was a new idea.

For some reason he just LOVES that costume.
I could probably pull off the Boo costume (though, I'd much rather just order it! LOL) but I'm afraid it might be too hot for her?? It sure would be cute though...Hmm I wonder what sort of monsters inc adult costumes there are (to buy..)
Your December plans look like so much fun! It's great how many new things/restaurants you are able to fit into such a short trip!!
No, I don't mind the PTR being for October & December (I'd be such a butthead if I said yes it bothered me since I turned mine into a DL PTR for awhile

).
No, I DEFINITELY don't mind the random updates and especially not the Aria pictures...keep those coming! Besides, the little life updates are what keep a PTR going sometimes when there are no trip plans in the works at the moment. At least that's what I do for mine...never thought to ask if people minded, maybe they always have and I never stopped to think of it?

I'm sure no one minds seeing pictures of cute babies!! At least, that's my perspective.
I just LOVE that your DH likes to dress up for Halloween just to hand out candy, although

for the poor kid who almost fell down the stairs.

I guess I'm not the best person to give suggestions for a costume idea since I never did figure anything else out for us either! But I think the Boo costume is an adorable idea!! I'm not creative at all either, so I guess that would be difficult to make, but if you can make it work, it will be so cute! Hopefully you come up with something. I found tons of cute baby Halloween costumes when looking for Paxton the past two years, so if you don't need it to be Disney themed, there are so many cute things to choose from now! My friend's little girl was a ladybug for her first Halloween, and it was just precious! I've also seen people dressing their little girls as a lamb or a bumblebee. I think I remember a really cute flower costume too!
LOL Okay I guess sometimes I think I update too much and it really has nothing to do with Disney which is why I asked. I like combined PTR's but I know someone who did two different ones and just was wondering if ppl preferred that...
Yeah I looove having all the new restaurants for the December trip, really makes it be set apart. Plus after that trip there's barely any restaurants we haven't been to!

And one more resort down, too.
A flower costume is a really cute idea too! There are a ton of cute baby costumes, I just want to make sure it isn't too hot you know? Thanks for the ideas though, I need to spend some computer time searching for some ideas for her...
I love seeing pics of Aria, I'm sure no one minds. I say put both PTR's on one, it's easier than starting over.
Whatever you decide for a costume, just make sure it's light and airy, we were there in October 2009 and it was still 91 degrees at midnight. Some kids were in full body costumes, I'd never seen kids sweat soo much.
I found a costume for Lia on Etsy, I tried it on her for a little photoshoot and it will still fit in October if we decide to do the Halloween party.
Aw I love it!! That's definitely something we could do - maybe a Belle costume and that'll be done. Especially if we don't want to dress up. IDK. I keep going back and forth.
I prefer having both your PTRs in one place. It's easier to keep track of them that way; I already feel like I'm following so many, lol!
I don't mind the personal updates (people can scroll through those if they do; it's
your report), and of course I love the Aria cuteness.
It was pretty easy for me to find Andrew's shirt on Etsy because there aren't as many options for boys. I can only imagine all of the adorable outfits there are for little girls!
A few years ago, my friends and their DD went to
MNSSHP as Peter Pan, Wendy and Tinkerbell. I don't know if you can get DH into tights, haha, but they looked really cute ... especially their DD as Tink!
***
Your December plans are spot-on. I would choose Garden Grill over Boatwright's, both for the food and the atmosphere; Yachtsman or Captain's Grille might have more of a nautical theme than Boatwright's...
Awww I LOVE

the Peter Pan, Wendy, and Tink idea! Now just to get DH out of his Jack Sparrow idea. Though Tink kinda still works with that, at least the pirate thing/Hook/etc? KWIM? Or am I grasping at straws?
We had an awful, awful time at Yachtsman's on our last trip!

It'll be a while before we go back there. Captain's Grill was okay though - thanks for the suggestions! Just wanted to try something new.
Just found your PTR and read through all of it. Congratulations on your baby girl, she is gorgeous!! Our first baby is due in just 8 short weeks, and we're taking him or her to Disney for the first time in January at 5-6 months old. I cannot wait to hear about both of your trips!
Wow congrats!!

So excited for you! I remember being 32/33 weeks preggo! I felt so great, I hope you do too.

Being pregnant was really wonderful. Where are you staying in January?! Kudos for keeping the gender a secret! LOL. I couldn't do it.
Finally back on the DiS after a month break... All caught up! I like the Dismey training with Aria! I will have to remember to do that!
Anyway, I would take the carriage ride at FW, just because it is something you can only do at certain times of the year. I think Aria will love the lights as well!
Welcome back!! Thanks - yeah! I need to go check out your PTR now that you're back. How are you feeling? "Disney training" is so much fun! LOL.
Looks like I gotta fit in the carriage ride at the FW...
I would go to boatwrights over Garden Grill. We really enjoy the food at Boatwrights and to us Garden Grill is just meh! I don't mind both PTR's being in one place but I'm hardly ever here anymore anyways. I'm still depressed over our February trip so it kinda stings hearing about other's wonderful trips and upcoming trips LOL. I'm just feeling sorry for myself because we're not going again until next December. SO far away! Anyways, I love DH's Jack costume!
Interesting!! Though I wanted to do Boatwrights on MK night, not GG/EPCOT night.
I'm so sorry about your Feb trip - I know what you mean about not coming on the DIS. There is always a lull for me after my trips bc I'm so depressed at them being over (and those are trips that went well, not ending awfully like yours did!). Hopefully that won't happen this time with multiple trips in the works and such (and writing a TR for the first time).