Just got back from Disney with my 3.5 year ols and my 20 mo and I wanted to pass on my experience. We took 2 strollers- my Graco Metrolite for my 20 mo and a Graco Umbroller (el cheapo) for my 3.5 yo. I liked the idea of 2 separate strollers so neither of us had to push some 90 lbs of kids/stroller all around WDW. On the other hand we spent a lot of time trading off on the adult rides. So one of would be stuck with 2 kids in 2 separate strollers. My 3.5 can walk and not wander of course so sometimes while DH was on a ride, I'd leave the Umbroller outside the ride and take just my 20 mo in the one stroller while she walked so we could do shopping while we waited. In retrospect, I think 2 of the exact high-end umbrella types and connextors (like from One Step Ahead) would've been ideal! So 2 NICE lightweight strollers with baskets, recline, canopies and connectos. That way we could hook them together or take them apart! Also, Disney is A LOT of in and out of the strollers. We drove to the parks so to get on the parking lot tram (whgich was my kids' favorite part of WDW BTW! LOL), we'd have to take them out, fold them strollers, etc, etc, bags, sippies, etc. ugh! Very few rides/attractions allow strollers in. Even The Living Seas allows strollers and yet no one realized we (along with EVERYONE ELSE) parked our strollers and lugged our kids around. Then I get inside there and I see a couple strollers and walked up to these people and asked "How did you get the stroller in here?!" UGH! You get so used to taking your kids in and out, in and out! Even Epcot's The Land- that whole building, restaurant and all is no strollers!
As far as theft goes- we used no locks. We planned to but we didn't and I didn't see anyone else doing it. Like I said, it's a lot of in and out! You'll be locking and unlocking all day! We once parked outside Pinnochio Haus and came out to find our stroller was moved into the stroller parking past "It's a Small World". We didn't realize we weren't in a legitimate parking area and the CM was nice enough to help us and apologize which of course wasn't necessary. So, we felt things were very safe. Felt a little nervous during Fantasmic because there's actually large stroller lots and then several thousand people in the ampitheater. I felt like anyone could just ransack everyone's strollers and no one would know. So for that, we were sure to take our belongings with us. Speaking of Fantasmic, they had everyone with rentals just park their strollers before entering the theater and then reclaim a stroller to take to the gate. I wonder if people who didn't rent at all borrowed strollers for sleepy kids and I thought, man, I'd be annoyed if I rented and then didn't have a stroller from Fantasmic all the way to the front gate!
I was thinking....yeah we should go next year and I know what I'll do stroller-wise but by then my 3.5 year old will be too big for any stroller probably. I did see several VERY old kids in rental strollers. I'm talking 10-12 year olds in strollers! I'm not kidding! I know when I was a kid my feet would get tired at the end of a long day at WDW but no way my parents would rent me a stroller! Thought that was pretty.....different....
BTW, rentals are $8 single (I think...) and $15 double. $15/day was just way too much we thought especially considering we went for 6 days. I can't imagine spending that, except for maybe next year when my daughter is too big for regulat strollers!