WDW Restaurant Survey: Table Service Edition!(Final Results!!)

[Yahweh]

I'll have the update standings ready shortly

 

[mamajab]

Wow. Didn't realize we had eaten in so many TS restaurants (45/81), or that we had missed so many others! Here's my list:
1. Victoria & Albert - yes, it's expensive, but it is, hands down, one of the best meals we have ever eaten
2. Yachtsman Steakhouse
3. California Grill
4. Be Our Guest
5. Jiko
6. LeCellier
7. Ohana
8. Boma
9. Flying Fish
10. Captain's Grille
11. Kona Café
12. Spice Road Table
13. Liberty Tree Tavern
14. Hoop Dee Doo Revue
15. Whispering Canyon
16. Wave
17. Tutto Italia
18. Sanaa
19. Via Napoli
20. Garden Grill
21. Biergarten
22. Skipper Canteen
23. Rose & Crown
24. Raglan Road
25. Hose of Blues

 

[Yahweh]

Update Results #2

After 45 submissions:

Rank-(Score) Restaurant -Total Points (#of times a Top 5 ranking)

1. (9.98) Boma- (449 Points)(12)
2. (9.67) Kona Cafe- (435 Points)(7)
3. (8.78) Tusker House- (395 Points)(10)
4. (8.64) Be Our Guest Dinner- (389 Points)(7)
5. (8.49) Ohana- (382 Points)(8)
6. (7.80) Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater- (351Points)(2)
7. (7.78) California Grill- (350 Points)(13)
8. (7.49) Via Napoli- (337 Points)(8)
9. (7.16) Crystal Palace- (322 Points)(2)
10. (6.71) The Wave- (302 Points)(9)
11. (6.15) Jiko- (277 Points)(8)
12. (5.93) The Hollywood Brown Derby- (267 Points)(3)
13. (5.73) Chefs de France- (258 Points)(2)
14. (5.44) Rose & Crown- (245 Points)(4)
15. (5.34) 50s Prime Time- (241 Points)(3)
16. (5.32) 1900 Park Faire- (240 Points)(2)
17. (5.28) Yak & Yeti- (238 Points)(2)
18. (5.24) Sanaa- (236 Points)(6)
19. (5.16) Cape May Cafe- (232 Points)(0)
20. (5.08) Le Cellier Steakhouse- (229 Points)(6)
21. (5.04) Cinderella's Royal Table- (227 Points)(3)
22. (4.87) Narcoossee’s- (219 Points)(6)
23. (4.71) San Angel Inn- (212 Points)(1)
24. (4.60) Raglan Road- (207 Points)(4)
25. (4.58) Biergarten- (206 Points)(4)
26. (4.56) Whispering Canyon Cafe- (205 Points)(1)
27. (4.47) Flying Fish- (201 Points)(5)
28. (4.36) Skipper Canteen- (197 Points)(4)
29. (4.33) Liberty Tree Tavern- (195 Points)(2)
30. (3.76) Beaches and Cream- (169 Points)(2)
31. (3.40) Akershus- (153 Points)(2)
32. (3.16) Todd English's Bluezoo- (142 Points)(4)
33. (3.16) Chef Art Smith's Homecomin’- (142 Points) (5)
34. (3.11) The Plaza- (140 Points)(2)
35. (2.93) Tokyo Dining- (132 Points)(2)
36. (2.93) Victoria & Albert’s- (132 Points)(4)
37. (2.93) Mama Melrose’s- (132 Points)(1)
38. (2.89) Hoop Dee Doo Revue- (130 Points)(2)
39. (2.78) Chef Mickey’s- (125 Points)(0)
40. (2.71) Captain’s Grill- (122 Points)(2)
41. (2.64) Garden Grill- (119 Points)(2)
42. (2.62) Artist Point- (118 Points)(2)
43. (2.59) Yachtsman Steakhouse- (117 Points)(2)
44. (2.57) Shula's Steak House- (116 Points)(4)
45. (2.53) Tiffins- (114 Points)(3)
46. (2.53) Teppan Edo- (114 Points)(3)
47. (2.53) Rainforest Cafe- (114 Points)(1)
48. (2.44) Nine Dragons- (110 Points)(3)
49. (2.40) Trail's End- (108 Points)(1)
50. (2.20) Citricos- (99 Points)(2)
51. (2.18) Monsieur Paul- (98 Points)(2)
52. (1.16) Boatwright’s Dining Hall- (97 Points)(2)
53. (2.02) Tutto Italia- (91 Points)(1)
54. (1.98) Grand Floridian Cafe- (89 Points)(0)
55. (1.71) Morimoto Asia- (77 Points)(2)
56. (1.65) Restauant Marrakesh- (74 Points)(0)
57. (1.65) Coral Reef- (74 Points)(0)
58. (1.31) Olivia’s- (59 Points)(0)
59. (1.27) Splitsville- (57 Points)(2)
60. (1.22) Tony’s Town Square- (55 Points)(0)
61. (1.22) The Boathouse- (55 Points)(2)
62. (1.16) T-Rex- (52 Points)(0)
63. (1.07) Kimonos- (48 points)(1)
64. (0.95) Big River Grill- (43 Points)(0)
65. (0.95) Bongos Cuban Cafe- (43 Points)(0)
66. (0.93) Hollywood and Vine- (42 Points)(1)
67. (0.91) Planet Hollywood- (41 Points)(0)
68. (0.89) Tattoria al Forno- (40 Points) (0)
69. (0.77) Paradiso 37- (35 Points)(0)
70. (0.73) Turf Club- (33 Points)(1)
71. (0.73) Spice Road Table- (33 Points)(0)
72. (0.69) Il Mulino- (31 Points)(1)
73. (0.67) Fountain- (30 Points)(0)
74. (0.58) Wolfgang Puck's Cafe- (26 Points)(1)
75. (0.51) Portobellos- (23 Points)- (1)
76. (0.51) La Hacienda de San Angel- (23 Points)(0)
77. (0.51) Garden Grove- (23 Points)(1)
78. (0.48) Spirit of Aloha- (22 Points)(0)
79. (0.33) Mickey’s Backyard BBQ- (15 Points) (0)
80. (0.31) House of Blues- (14 Points) (0)
81. (0.31) Garden View Tea- (14 Points) (0)
82. (0.11)Las Ventanas- (5 Points) (0)

 

[Yahweh]

Wow. Didn't realize we had eaten in so many TS restaurants (45/81), or that we had missed so many others! Here's my list:

I'll add your list to the next update

 

[Yahweh]

A lot of surprises so far!

 

[DaisyDuck001]

#61 and #64 above appear to be two names for the same restaurant.

 

[Planogirl]

#61 and #64 above appear to be two names for the same restaurant.

Good catch!

I wonder if I should list bottom three. Is anything being done with those?

 

[bwbuddy5]

I think there may be some confusion concerning San Angel Inn and La Hacienda de San Angel, maybe some voting for the wrong one? For those of you who have been to both, describe the difference in menu and location.

Great list, Yahweh, helps me make some choices about our upcoming trip and now I don't feel embarrassed to admit Sci-Fi is always on our must do list!

 

[Yahweh]

#61 and #64 above appear to be two names for the same restaurant.

Fixed. Yeah sorry about that. On the second update I added a new Boatwright's by a mistake. Went through all the lists and when you add the two together it adds up correctly. Thanks for catching that.

 

[Yahweh]

I think there may be some confusion concerning San Angel Inn and La Hacienda de San Angel, maybe some voting for the wrong one? For those of you who have been to both, describe the difference in menu and location.

Great list, Yahweh, helps me make some choices about our upcoming trip and now I don't feel embarrassed to admit Sci-Fi is always on our must do list!

Yeah you're probably right, typically people will say that La Hacienda is the better of the two, but the survey doesn't reflect that.

 

[klacey1]

Fun idea! Going to do top 10

1. Yachtsman Steakhouse
2. bluezoo
3. Biergarten
4. Artist Point
5. Raglan Road
6. Rose and Crown
7. Whispering Canyon Cafe
8. Il Mulino
9. La Hacienda de San Angel
10. T-Rex Cafe

 

[Yahweh]

Good catch!

I wonder if I should list bottom three. Is anything being done with those?

I may at some point do a bottom three ranking. But list away. When people read through the thread any information can be useful

 

[disneyAndi14]

Here goes......
1. Ohana
2. Sanaa
3. Tusker House
4. Yak and Yeti
5. Via Napoli
6. Garden Grill
7. Sci-Fi
8. 50's PT
9. The Wave
10. Boma
11. Cinderella Royal Table
12. Liberty Tree Tavern
13. BoG
14. Mama Melrose
15. The Boathouse
16. Splitsville
17. The Plaza
18. Tokyo Dining
19. The Kona
20. Chefs de France
21. Biergarten
22. Cape May cafe
23. Trails End
24. Nine Dragons
25. Skippers Canteen

 

[georgina]

Haven't read through the thread. I really wish you would change your user name, OP. I can't have been the only person through the years who was offended you would use that for your name.

 

[Planogirl]

I may at some point do a bottom three ranking. But list away. When people read through the thread any information can be useful

I appreciate the trouble. Even though the rankings do penalize newer restaurants it's still fun.

Bottom three:
Chef Mickey
Hollywood & Vine
Akershus

 

[Yahweh]

Haven't read through the thread. I really wish you would change your user name, OP. I can't have been the only person through the years who was offended you would use that for your name.

I'll change it without any issue Send me a private message if you would and we can talk about it. I'm more curious than anything else. When I made this account I was writing my thesis which was in theology, and simply choose that as my account name so I'd remember. I never thought I'd end up posted anything, let alone offend anyone.

 

[Yahweh]

I appreciate the trouble. Even though the rankings do penalize newer restaurants it's still fun.

Akershus

Yeah I know I wish I could figure out a way not have that happen, other than time!

 

[Yahweh]

Haven't read through the thread. I really wish you would change your user name, OP. I can't have been the only person through the years who was offended you would use that for your name.

Tried to change it, apparently you can't

 

[Chrelaine]

Of the TS where we have eaten:
1. 'Ohana
2. Via Napoli
3. The Wave
4. Olivia's
5. The Boathouse
6. La Hacienda de San Angel
7. Portobello
8. Grand Floridian Cafe
9. Hollywood & Vine
10. Akershus
11. Tusker House
12. T-Rex
13. Tony's

 

[squeezle]

It it's not too late:

1. 50's Prime Time
2. Sanaa
3. Morimoto's
4. Kona Cafe
5. Tiffins
6. Hollywood Brown Derby
7. The Wave
8. Flying Fish
9. Ragland Road
10. Restaurant Marrakesh
11. Spice Road Table
12. Morimoto's
13. Yak & Yeti
14. Narcoossee's
15. Liberty Tree Tavern