WDW Restaurant Survey: Table Service Edition!(Final Results!!)

[sweetmama17]

Tusker House (lunch)
Via Napoli
Nine Dragons
Restaurant Marrakesh
The Plaza
Crystal Palace (lunch)
Garden Grove (breakfast)
Sci-Fi
Whispering Canyon
Rainforest Cafe
T-Rex
Bongos

Honestly all the table service we have ate at we have viewed as fine, not outstanding nor awful. There are quick service places that I view as awful but all the table service is a little step above all the quick service.

Excited to try Skipper, Cape may breakfast, and H&V (not really, but if it helps get my kid signed up for Jedi how bad can a 20% off breakfast be)

 

[Yahweh]

Update results are on the first page- Any rankings after NCO91590 will be added to rankings update #2

 

[bwbuddy5]

Should we rank based on food only, or overall experience? Sci Fi would be close to the top for us based on experience, we go every trip, but closer to the bottom on food only (but still okay)

 

[Yahweh]

Vote on overall experience. I put

Should we rank based on food only, or overall experience? Sci Fi would be close to the top for us based on experience, we go every trip, but closer to the bottom on food only (but still okay)

I tend to think of this as an over-all experience restaurant rankings. For myself, food quality and service have the largest impact upon my overall experience of a restaurant. But many others may have different priorities in this regard. So whatever makes your favourite restaurants your favourite, vote that way

 

[Elleshoodat]

I thought I'd eaten at more table-service restaurants, but here goes:

1. Via Napoli
2. The BOATHOUSE
3. Kona Cafe
4. Beaches and Cream
5. The Plaza
6. Bongo's Cuban Cafe
7. Paradiso 37
8. Boatwright's Dining Hall
9. Hoop-Dee-Doo Musical Revue
10. Cape May Cafe
11. Planet Hollywood

 

[Yahweh]

I thought I'd eaten at more table-service restaurants, but here goes:

1. Via Napoli
2. The BOATHOUSE
3. Kona Cafe
4. Beaches and Cream
5. The Plaza
6. Bongo's Cuban Cafe
7. Paradiso 37
8. Boatwright's Dining Hall
9. Hoop-Dee-Doo Musical Revue
10. Cape May Cafe
11. Planet Hollywood

I'm glad to see the Boathouse get a high vote! I've haven't been there yet, but have heard really good things.

 

[Elleshoodat]

I'm glad to see the Boathouse get a high vote! I've haven't been there yet, but have heard really good things.

It's wonderful! The food is delicious, the atmosphere is casual yet refined (we love the open-air main dining room), and there's something for everyone in our family. Hopefully you enjoy it when you get there.

 

[Owl X]

1. Biergarten
2. Il Mulino
3. Le Cellier Steakhouse
   
4. Todd English's Bluezoo
5. Tusker House
6. Liberty Tree Tavern
7. 50s Prime Time
8. Hollywood Brown Derby
9. Rose & Crown
10. Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater
11. Tutto Italia
12. Boma
    
13. Via Napoli
14. Akershus
    
15. Trattoria al Forno
16. Restaurant Marrakesh
17. Mama Melrose’s
18. Tony’s Town Square
19. Coral Reef
    
20. Garden Grill
    
21. Rainforest Cafe
22. Planet Hollywood

 

[GXIncognto]

Just a top 20, haven't quite been to 25:

1. ‘Ohana
2. Le Cellier
3. Boma
4. Citricos
5. Hollywood Brown Derby
6. Grand Floridian Cafe
7. Crystal Palace
8. Monsieur Paul
9. Cinderella’s Royal Table
10. Tusker House
11. Be Our Guest
12. Spice Road Table
13. Yak and Yeti
14. Whispering Canyon Café
15. Sanaa
16. Tutto Italia
17. Chef Mickey’s
18. Turf Club
19. Kona Café
20. Olivia’s Café

 

[DisneyFansInNYC]

This was so hard. We have so many favorites.

1 Ohana
2 Boma
3 Sanaa
4 Kona Cafe
5 Hoop Dee Doo
6 The Wave
7 Whispering Canyon Café
8 Via Napoli
9 Liberty Tree Tavern
10 Akershus
11 Garden Grill
12 Sci Fi
13 Brown Derby
14 Biergarten
15 1900 Park Fare
16 50’s Prime Time
17 San Angel Inn
18 Tusker House
19 Trail’s End
20 Yak & Yeti
21 Nine Dragons
22 Rose and Crown
23 Be Our Guest
24 Marrakesh
25 Plaza

 

[agavegirl1]

I'll rank the ones I've actually eaten at...

1. Monsieur Paul

2. Boma

3. Shulas

4. Biergarten

5. Raglan Road

6. Cape May

7. Be Our Guest

8. 50’s Prime Time

9. Teppan Edo

10. Yak and Yeti

11. Beaches and Cream

12. Big River Grill

13. Hollywood Brown Derby

14. Crystal Palace

15. Liberty Tree Tavern

16. Hollywood and Vine

17. Rainforest Café Animal Kingdom

18. Planet Hollywood

 

[Clare Voince]

1. Shula's
2. Biergarten
3. Narcoossee's
4. California Grill
5. Trail's End
6. Rose & Crown
7. Kona Café
8. Yachtsman Steakhouse
9. Via Napoli
10. Beaches and Cream
11. Le Cellier
12. Ohana
13. Liberty Tree Tavern
14. Big River Grill
15. The Fountain
16. Chefs de France
17. Whispering Canyon Café
18. Sci-Fi Dine-In theater

 

[carlymcqueen]

1. Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater
2. Be Our Guest Restaurant
3. 50's Prime Time Cafe
4. Rainforest Cafe
5. The Plaza
6. Crystal Palace
7. Skipper Canteen
8. 1900 Park Fare
9. The Wave
10. T-REX
11. The Hollywood Brown Derby
12. Tony's Town Square
13. Restaurant Marrakesh
14. Artist Point
15. Spirit of Aloha Dinner Show
16. Chef Mickey's

 

[Trap]

skipper canteen
yak and yeti
akershus breakfast
liberty tree tavern
50 prime time
yachtsman
be our guest
crystal palace
nine dragons
mama melrose
san angel inn
whispering canyon
the plaza
le cellier
biergaten
sci fi
boatwrights
rainforest

 

[donkeykong91]

Thank you for compiling these lists! Here is mine:

1) California Grill
2) Tiffins
3) Citricos
4) Skipper Canteen
5) Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater
6) Boma
7) Tusker House
8) La Hacienda de San Angel
9) Raglan Road
10) Chef Art Smith's Homecomin’
11) The Hollywood Brown Derby
12) Jiko
13) Sanaa
14) Rose and Crown
15) Morimoto Asia
16) Liberty Tree Tavern
17) Be Our Guest Restaurant
18) Cinderella's Royal Table
19) Il Mulino
20) Tutto Italia
21) Monsieur Paul
22) Akershus Royal Banquet Hall
23) Paradiso 37
24) San Angel Inn
25) Kona Cafe

 

[Megara5115]

1. Victoria and Alberts
2. Boma
3. Boathouse
4. Saana
5. Be Our Guest
6. Biergarten
7. Narcoossee
8. Hollywood Brown Derby
9. Yak and Yeti
10. Trails End
11. Ohana
12. Homecoming

 

[Dr Gevil]

My top ten I would go to every visit if I could.

1. V&A's
2. Morimoto Asia
3. Homecoming
4. Sanaa
5. Jiko
6. bluezoo
7. California Grill
8. Narcoossee's
9. Trattoria al Forno - undervalued gem
10. Hoop Dee Doo Review
11. Boma
12. Chefs De France
13. Kimonos
14. Via Napoli
15. Flying Fish
16. Yachtmans Steakhouse
17. Artist Point
18. The Boathouse
19. Splitsville - surprisingly good food here - including sushi!
20. Olivia's - another undervalued gem
21. 50's Prime Time Cafe
22. Restaurant Marrakesh
23. Teppan Edo
24. Cape May Cafe
25. Whispering Canyon Cafe

 

[krdindy]

1. Via Napoli
2. Ohana
3. Boma
4. Crystal Palace
5. Tusker House
6. Be Our Guest
7. T-Rex
8. 50's Prime Time Cafe
9. Hoop De Doo Musical Revue
10. Cape May Cafe
11. Cinderella's Royal Table
12. Akershus
13. Sci-Fi Dine In Theater
14. Hollywood and Vine
15. The Plaza
16. Garden Grill
17. Beaches and Cream
18. Kona Cafe
19. 1900 Park Fare
20. Whispering Canyon Cafe
21. Sanaa
22. Liberty Tree Tavern
23. Chef Mickey's
24. Coral Reef
25. Mama Melrose

 

[vcr0414]

1. Jiko
2. Flying Fish
3. California Grill
4. San Angel
5. Brown Derby

 

[DaisyDuck001]

1. Tusker House
2. Skipper Canteen
3. The Wave
4. Rose and Crown
5. Captain's Grille
6. Boma
7. Sci Fi Dine In
8. Boatwright's Dining Hall
9. Artist Point
10. Garden Grill (breakfast only)
11. 1900 Park Fare
12. Garden View Tea
13. Jiko
14. Whispering Canyon Café
15. Raglan Road
16. Kona Café (This used to be among my top favorites, but the new lunch and dinner menus they recently published don't appeal to me at all; I wish they would bring back the Polynesian plate lunch)
17. Crystal Palace
18. Cape May Café (breakfast only)
19. Biergarten
20. San Angel Inn
21. Wolfgang Puck Cafe
22. Le Cellier
23. Olivia's
24. Coral Reef
25. Liberty Tree Tavern (I liked this one better when it was a character dinner)

And three that I don't like:
1. BOG lunch
2. Trail's End dinner
3. T-Rex food (but I do like the decor)