Was this in bad taste, on my part?

redshoes

<font color=red>I'm sitting here watching the new
Joined
Feb 2, 2006
Messages
1,879
I'm trying to figure out if I should play into the massive guilt trip my mother has unloaded on me this past weekend or if if I can ignore it and move on. Give me your HONEST opinion, I'm not just saying that and then when someone does I'm going to get mad:

Okay here's the issue: My only sibling (a brother) got married on Saturday. My mother is strange when it comes to him, he is her baby and she and my Dad have always cuddled him. My oldest son was the ring bearer. My DH, me, DS(3) and DS(2) were invitied to the ceremony and reception afterwords. The events started at 3pm and went to 8pm. My family and I attended the ceremony, we chatted with the our extended family, we talked for a short time period to the bride and groom, we helped setup chairs and greeted guests. I felt like we did the things that were asked of us. The couple was to get married at 4 o'clock, didn't happen, they ran 45 minutes behind. My three year old did great as the ring bearer and was very patient, my two year is another story. He was thankfully quiet for the actual ceremony, but afterwards it was fit after fit. In his defense, he has a bit of social anxiety (can two year olds have that?) in loud, large groups.

Now, the reception was not a formal sitdown dinner affair. Just a greeting line of the new couple and their parents along with some light refreshments. There was nothing for the guests to do but eat and chat. It was inside in a senior citizen center (please dont ask) and not really what I would consider a reception hall. We left at 7pm, our boys were tired and there was nothing for them or us to really do but sit at a table and take up valuable space for people who were attending the reception. We made sure that we said our goodbyes and left to put the boys to bed.

I got a call yesterday from my mother who asked me how the wedding went (I think she was baiting me). I told her I thought it was very nice and that I was happy that things went so well. She and my Dad had just got back from picking up the bride and groom at their hotel to take them to the airport at 6am for their honeymoon flight(these are 28 year old adults). I told her I thought that was strange why didnt they get a taxi- I think this put her on the defense and it was honestly not intentional on my part. She went on to tell me that she was disappointed that we didnt stay to cleanup after the reception, she said that the bride's nephews that our close to my boys ages were there the whole time and they were perfectly behaved and why couldn't my boys have stayed. I told her that I honestly didnt feel like I missed out on anything, that we were there for the ceremony and part of the reception and that I would rather have left when the boys were half way decent than to push them past the point of good behavior and have them be the children that everyone points at and asks who's their mother. She told me that was a poor excuse and that my brother and new SIL were going to have a hard time forgiving us since we (DH and I) didnt make an effort to celebrate their special day.

Am I wrong, I felt like we did our part. We celebrated with the couple and we are thrilled for them, but I have my own little family to take care of and worry about too.
 
You did exactly what I would have done. I wouldn't worry about it.

Why should you have been expected to stay and clean up? You helped set up and greet guest and other stuff. Your first obligation is to your children. If the bride and groom wanted help clean up they should have asked people in advance not just expected it.
 
Mom is being a witch and you did your duty and then some. In your position I would have done the same thing. If I knew before hand it might have been a big deal we probably would have done the two car thing and I would have stayed while my wife took the kids home, but not knowing that she would make a big deal out of it before hand probably not. I would wait and hear what your brother says before you lose too much sleep over it. Your mom might just be cranky due to the big event stress and the early morning airport drop off.
 
Did you agree in advance to help clean up after the reception? If so, then maybe you shouldn't have bailed on them, but if not, I don't see the least bit of problem with you leaving an hour early.
 

You want my honest opinion?

I think that your mother was way out of line! You did your part, you stayed as long as you could, you helped out as best you could, and for them to expect you to clean up is beyond my comprehension!

We had a very simple wedding (almost 24 years ago) and I sure wouldn't have expected my family to clean up more than they were able. We have our kids bar/bat mitzvah parties in our house and our families do pitch in and help out, but we hire a caterer to do the bulk of the work. Any work that family does is a bonus and I'm thankful for the help.

I wouldn't complain when someone has helped and they can't do more due to the meltdowns that their kids would be getting ready to go through (been there, done that, and I certainly understand how that works)!

To make peace with your brother and his wife, I might tell them that you had a great time at their wedding, tell them that you wish that you could have stayed longer, but your kids were very tires and reaching the breaking point, and leave it at that. Don't bring up what your mother said--maybe they don't share the same feelings.

Good luck!!!
 
You done good, kiddo. :thumbsup2

I would have done the same thing, under the circumstances.

Seems odd that your brother and his wife were so overly concerned about your whereabouts on their wedding day that they'll have a hard time forgiving you. You might want to ask your mother why she thinks YOU were their primary concen on their special day.

I'll bet, when the newlyweds return from their honeymoon and you ask for their forgiveness, that they'll have no idea what you are talking about.

Ignore your mother. You did the right thing.
 
:grouphug: I don't think you did a thing wrong. You helped set up, you greeted guests. The wedding party were 45 minutes late and you still stayed until an hour before the end. You left to take care of your own children and their needs. That many boring hours is tough on any two year old. If, as your mother points out, your brother and new SIL will be hard pressed to forgive you, then they are very hard hearted people in my opinion.

Had I been your sister getting married I would have appreciated you doing all you did for me and staying as long as you did even though we ran late. I would have appreciated you thinking enough of me and my other guests to remove a cranky, unhappy two year old and taking him home when there was only an hour left anyway.

Don't let Mom make you feel bad. I don't think you've done anything to be sorry for.
 
Marseeya said:
Did you agree in advance to help clean up after the reception? If so, then maybe you shouldn't have bailed on them, but if not, I don't see the least bit of problem with you leaving an hour early.

Nope, I actually told her that we would be lucky to make it past 7 (my boys go to bed at 8)but that we would do our best.
 
I don't think you should feel bad about anything. Why should you have stayed and helped clean up? Did your DB help clean up at your reception, probably not considering your parents want to hold his hand through life. She is trying to take you on the guilt train, don't play into it.
 
SC Minnie is right. They should have made sure that they had relatives and friends lined up before the reception if they needed a clean up crew. Furthermore, this crew should have been childless people, or those with children old enough to stay up late without melting down.

Your mother is wrong. You can tell her I said so. ;)

Weddings bring out the best and the worst in people. After my brother and SIL were married, her sister sent them a very nasty note. Her sister wasn't asked to be MOH, yet she figured that she would be the Matron of Honor. When her name was in the program as a BM, she was very angry. It'll be 10 years in July that my brother and SIL are married. SIL and her sister have only spoken in single syllables when their father was in the hospital. My SIL knows she did nothing wrong. Where did her sister go thinking that she was going to have a bigger role than she was asked to have? Frankly, why is your mother thinking you should have had a bigger role than you did? I'm sure that your brother and SIL are happy that you shared in their day. If you let your mother get caught in the middle, she'll only cause problems for you.

I'm sure that your brother will understand one day when he has toddlers. Parents have to be on the kids' clocks, not the other way around.
 
My opinon differs slightly from the others.
This was a very speical day for brother and maybe you should have stayed and sent DH home with the kiddies.
I understand you have an obligation to them, and their welfare, but DH could have taken care of them and you might have avoided making mom mad.
 
If you never talked to your parents again, I wouldn't blame you one bit. Your mother is very cruel to you.

My guess is your life is good, your dh is great, you have a nice family and she hates that. She tries to tear you down.

I would certainly keep my distance and NEVER EVER leave her with your children ALONE.
 
I think the only mistake you made was if you really said "you didn't feel like you had missed anything" or if you expressed to anyone your feelings about where the reception was held. It made perfect sense IMO for you to leave when you did, however those comments would have hurt my feelings.

I have to add that my FIL ended up driving us to our airport hotel after our wedding. It wasn't our original plan, but we got married in a storm and he had four wheel drive with snow/ice tires. It just worked out that way, and although it wasn't my favorite way to leave the church it wasn't a big deal - but I would have been mad if someone made a deal out of it.

I would ignore your mom. I'm sure your brother and new SIL thought nothing about it one way or the other and that your mom is just being cranky. If it comes up, stick to "leaving because you didn't want the kids to start behaving poorly and ruin their special day" and leave out the "we didn't miss anything" part.
 
Poor taste....absolutely not! The kids were tired and cranky, you SET up, and my Lord you just left an hour early. Its not like you bolted as soon as the ceremony was over. I'd tell dear old mum to bite me
 
I agree with the others. Your mother was wrong. I would of done the same thing you did. Chances are your brother and SIL may not even be as hurt or angry as she said. If so then they are selfish and horrible too. Don't worry about it.
 
No, you did nothing in bad taste IMO.
Your mother, however was rude in telling you that your brother may not forgive you. If your brother has a problem w/ you leaving early then he should address it w/ you, not really your mothers business.
I would have taken the kids home early also.
 
You did the right thing, I would have done the same thing.
 
mrsdon said:
My opinon differs slightly from the others.
This was a very speical day for brother and maybe you should have stayed and sent DH home with the kiddies.
I understand you have an obligation to them, and their welfare, but DH could have taken care of them and you might have avoided making mom mad.

I'm gonna side with my dear Deb here.

It was your brothers wedding and like it or not IMO blood relatives and the wedding party are required to stick it out to the bitter end. I definetely would have sent DH home with the kids.

My best friend got married 18 months ago, I was in the wedding. When my DS got tired, DH packed him up and returned to the hotel. I waited until it was over and then bowed out of the post wedding activities that the childless people were doing.

While I don't think your mother should have guilt tripped you (that is very rude IMO) I also don't see the harm in splitting up so you can do your family "duty" and your kids can get rest.

ETA - I also think that if your brother had a problem he should talk to you about it. It isn't your mom's place to 'create' problems between you and your brother over issues that may/may not exist.

I don't have siblings but I know my DH would have been hurt if his sister bailed out of his wedding early.

But I don't see where it is your mother's place to be mad at you especially about the cleaning up.
 
RadioNate said:
I'm gonna side with my dear Deb here.

It was your brothers wedding and like it or not IMO blood relatives and the wedding party are required to stick it out to the bitter end. I definetely would have sent DH home with the kids.

My best friend got married 18 months ago, I was in the wedding. When my DS got tired, DH packed him up and returned to the hotel. I waited until it was over and then bowed out of the post wedding activities that the childless people were doing.

While I don't think your mother should have guilt tripped you (that is very rude IMO) I also don't see the harm in splitting up so you can do your family "duty" and your kids can get rest.

Yeah, what you said.
 
Well, if it makes you feel any better, we left my sister's reception at 10:00 (it was scheduled to go to midnight) because it was SO boring and I was the maid of honor. No one missed us though.

I don't think you did anything wrong. I don't understand why arrangements weren't made for clean up before hand. Also, why would you have people at a wedding and reception from 3 until way past normal dinner time and not serve them a meal? Sorry, but your Brother was the rude one in this situation and your mom a close second. I would blow it off, especially since you know in your mom's eyes that your brother is perfect and you are not.

My mom is the same way with my sisters, they are perfect, I am not. We get a long a LOT better now that I never see my mom :goodvibes .
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top Bottom