Before AKL came along, WL was the most returned-to hotel on property. Lots of people love it, yet us VWL owners almost have to be apologists (said tongue-in-cheek, not defensively). We have stayed at all of the WDW
DVC resorts, and VWL is consistently our favorite. After a frenetic day at the parks the tranquil atmosphere of VWL settles us right down. Of course, any place that plays Aaron Copeland over the PA is going to win me over. When it comes to transporting the guest to another place, VWL has no equal.
I also don't get the whole location thing. Lets face it, WDW isn't all that big a place. Of course, that's from the perspective of someone who almost always drives. We take our car everywhere on property. BVC is walking distance from EPCOT - not a big deal. After a long day walking around Every Person Comes out Tired, who says, "We have to go back to our room now. I can't wait to walk some more!"? Car, bus, limo, even a hearse - just give me something where my feet don't have to hit the pavement after EPCOT.
If relaxation is a top vacation priority for you, as it is for us, VWL is the place for you. If you like lots of trees and peace and quiet, ditto. If you like to have a little fun, even on non-park days, the watermouses (watermice?) are faster than at BVC, too.