Saw this thread at lunch today and really wanted to post, but knew I didn't have time.
The beach resorts are our favorites. They are smaller resorts and the CM's just seemed to be more connected, happy, and involved in a variety of areas. The kids programs at both HHI & VB are wonderful. VB is my personal favorite, but I'll try not to show my bias with trying to point out the differences.
I think the most significant difference is that VB is ocean front and HHI is on the interconnector waterway with an ocean front beach house about a mile and a half away.
If you are a beach lover and enjoy playing in the waves then VB may be the better choice. HHI is relatively calm and shallow wereas VB has significant waves.
On the other hand, if you have young children (< 8) that you want to have on the beach, but don't want to have to tether them to something or watch them every second, then HHI will give you a more relaxing sit on the beach not having to worry about your little one getting clobbard and sucked under by the ocean trolls.
Then again, the beach on HHI is has many, many, many more people on it. If you are thinking about going in June then expect to share the beach with thousands of other people. At VB to have a hundred people on the beach would be a very active day.
I am a wildlife lover and both resorts offer abundant wildlife. I think perhaps the wildlife is closer to you and of a little greater variety at HHI because of the marsh land that comes up to the resort. Though if sea turtles are of interest the VB are is about the most active area on the US east coast.
Both resorts are great for biking. HHI is pretty spread out and it is fun just even bike around the resort. Then they also have a path that you can take to the beach house. VB is much more compact and biking is more enjoyable taking the resort tunnel under the highway to the Jungle trail that goes 8 miles to Pelican Island.
VB has 2 onsite restarants, 1 grille, and 1 bar/grille and are open until late into the evening or after midnight. HHI has only a snack/grille that must close after 5pm due to HH zoning regulations. On the other hand, HHI has a much wider variety of restaurants and eateries within easy walking distance just off the resort and ton of others just a short drive away.
I prefer VB for the waves and to have everything in one spot, but I still visit HHI on occasion for the variety of nature. Hope I helped some.
