I know what you mean about feeling like stuff is caked on your face. Even with professional facepainters, sometimes I see them using cheap, low quality, thick, itchy makeup ....yuck!.....and it makes me angry, esp. when it's on little kids.

Since you've used Ben Nye, you know what good makeup is. I've never used it myself because it's too expensive for what I do on a regular basis, but I know the quality. I use Mehron, or Snazaroo which are both less expensive, but still good. I order mine online because I can order the separate colors that I want, but I know that "Display and Costume" stores here in WA carry those lines also. I don't know about eveywhere else, but here, I can't just get one color there, so that's why I order it online. As far as the shades, there are only 2 shades of green, but I have about 18 colors and mix them to what I want. I have really sensitive skin and I can tolerate it on me without any problem. When you mix it with a little bit of water and sponge it on, it is so light that you really don't know it's there, and it doesn't crack or peel, etc. Whatever you decide, I can't wait to see your costume!...It sounds awesome! I will be bringing my paints/makeup with me to DLR anyway for myself and for others who might want to get a little something done before the party, so you are welcome to stop by and see if it works for you. We'll be doing the party on Wed., but I'm beginning to get a little sad that I'll miss seeing everyone in their costumes. I hope everyone gets lots of pics!