Honestly, you can't get someone who's determined to think a trip to WDW is for kids/nerdy to fully embrace the magic. It will have to find them on its own, or you'll end up tiring yourself out. I always find that my older sister's boyfriends who are like that end up really getting into things once they see all the other men that are there and are acting like big kids again. I think they're always afraid of looking dumb or feeling stupid and when that fear is taken away they're able to have a lot of fun.
Make sure to take some extra time at the World Showcase in Epcot, avoid any kind of character dining for this first trip, and ensure that you guys have plenty of time to do some recreational things. Golfing and renting boats are both a lot of fun, and so is parasailing from the Contemporary! Spend some time at your resort pool, and visit Trader Sam's at the Poly.Go see a movie at the AMC at Disney Springs, or go bowling there. Hit up some of the bars/lounges at the deluxe resort. Plan a spa afternoon for the two of you at one of the spas on property. There's plenty to do on a Disney World vacation that isn't in the parks!
Good advice for OP--let him know how much fun you're having & how much it means to have him there with you. I also agree with the idea of letting Disney work its magic on your non-fans. On a practical note: Keep 'em out of the lines & hot sun as much as possible.My DH is not a Disney fan, but will go with me every few years because he knows it makes me happy.
I'm headed to Disney in November with my boyfriend's family for a week long vacation. For me (28, new but huge fans of the parks), this is a guaranteed great time. My boyfriend (34, not much of a Disney fan) thinks the parks are just for kids or adults who loooooooove Disney. He doesn't dislike Disney, but I certainly wouldn't call him a fan, and he's the kind to roll his eyes at the idea of "Disney magic." What do I do??
Take him to Food & Wine on a Saturday night-MISSION:ACCOMPLISHED!![]()
The one thing you don't want to do is try really hard to convince him ahead of time that he's going to looooove it. Repeated attempts to make him "see the magic" will turn him right off. He's going. You don't need to talk him into the trip. Let him find his own enjoyment in it once he's there.
Another big turnoff for non-fans is overplanning. I mean, yeah, you need to plan some, it's fine to plan, but don't be spamming his e-mail inbox with schedules and spreadsheets. Do the work you need to do to make the trip go well, but do it in the background.