The first day is always Tide Me Over for Mickey waffles. After that it's breakfast in the villa
We spend 1-2 days on the beach.
One day at the beach house pool (on pool game day) and arcade/games etc
One day at the resort pool (on pool game day)
One day we devote to resort activities or crafts.
Evenings we bike ride, go to the outdoor movie, camp fire sing along and Smores, go play mini golf. I take an afternoon while DH and the kids fish to lay on the hammock and read.
If it's raining we borrow movies from the mercantile or board games from the front desk.
We've done a dolphin tour, gone to the coastal discovery museum, went kayaking, went to the movies, taken a hand crabbing trip but we've never left the island once we get there.