froggygrrrl
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2006
- Messages
- 1,004
Oh I don't think he's a creepy manipulator! Have you read the notes she has on Jacob on her site? I just think he's a typical, stubborn sixteen year old boy, who has a crush on a girl.
But then again I'm Team Switzerland (I read someone on the Breaking Dawn Spoiler Thread worded it something like: ideally I'm team Edward, but really team Switzerland)
That was me that wrote it. You'll have to forgive me if I didn't get my point across well enough as I may have been slightly tipsy at the time (but that won't stop me from talking about Twilight!)

What I meant by that was that of course I think Bella should end up with Edward. The whole series is set up for that to happen. And really, who would object to having an extremely hot boyfriend who is also strong, intelligent, and would do anything to make sure you are safe. But, I really don't have anything against Jacob. He just seems like the everyday, run-of-the-mill angsty teen who doesn't quite know how to deal with his emotions, so he acts out. In his defense, he certainly wasn't given very much time to be a teenager before he was thrown into very adult responsibilities like defending the reservation.
So, yes, ideally I am Team Edward because I would like the natural progression of the storyline to go this way. But I do have some compassion for Jake and think that he and Bella should still be in each other's lives, and if they happened to be more than friends I wouldn't think that the book had failed. So, really Team Switzerland.
Maybe that explains it better. If not, I don't have any more excuses, as I am completely sober now.