Tutto or LeCellier?

[ProudMommyof2]

WHich would you choose and why?

 

[NuttyDisneyMom]

Haven't been to Tutto, and I'm afraid to since I am Italian and am VERY fussy about my red sauce and pasta as most Italians are. But I have been to Le Cellier very recently and it was DELICIOUS! We are going back this fall

 

[danny1649]

Better food and great cast of servers and is on our must do list each visit to Epcot.

 

[dzneelvr]

I'm a firm believer in using the information on the boards but making sure you don't eliminate something you haven't tried based on the advice...make sense? We love both for entirely different reasons. If you are torn, try one for lunch and the other for dinner a different date. (detailed menus are on allearsnet.com) Seriously, they are both wonderful. Check out the Oh Canada! 360degree movie while you are waiting for your ADR and in Italy, be sure to browse the shop for fabulous Italian products and the fountain area makes a great photo. I say eat your way around the world and decide for yourself. We did!

 

[MickeyNicki]

Tough one! I would choose Tutto Italia because I love everything about all their food, just fantastic stuff! Plus they have cutesy waiters with nice accents and they called me Bella

Le Cellier is still very very good but I am not a fan of the cheese soup, the pretzel sticks are nice and the filet is good but not all that it is hyped up to be

 

[jana616]

Such a great question! I was wondering this exact same thing. We'll be there in September for FD, and I felt like I should try for a Le Cellier ADR just because they're so hard to get. Tutto was going to be my back-up. But the more I read about Tutto, the better it sounds. Hardly anyone has said it wasn't all they hoped, but Le Cellier seems so hyped it will be hard for it be live up to expectations. We are only doing one or the other, as we are taking our 5 and 2 year olds and are doing mainly "fun" meals. What to do? Does Tutto have a steak? Is it good? And I keep seeing pictures of a pasta dish that's round ravioli-type pasta in a cream sauce-the pasta looks like little pillows and it makes me drool everytime I see it. What dish is this, and is it still there and as good as it looks?

 

[PrincessMomto2]

We are lucky enough to be trying both in June for the first time. Tutto for dinner and LeCellier for lunch (wanted Dinner but it was not available except for a 8:45 ADR but with kids that was out of the question). I use to absolutley love Alfredo's (went years ago) and it was fantastic.

I wish we were going to be at Epcot a third night so I could try Chefs too!

 

[michelle1]

They are both really good, no complaints from us about either. They are completely different...do you prefer Italian or steaks? Our last visit I couldn't get and ADR at Le Cellier so the choice was made for me but we had a great meal at Tutto.

 

[patpaxton]

Tutto is good Italian. We enjoy it, but you can get good Italian in most cities around the country/world. LeCellier, on the other hand, has a filet like nothing I've ever tasted...and I'm a very dedicated steakhouse lover. Absolutely fantastic.

 

[WDWCNY]

LeCellier is my favorite resturant. Everthing I have eaten there is great. DMIL and DFIL are both italian and loed the food at Tutto. DH and myself have yet to eat there. I am picky about my italian food. Maybe try n next trip in October.

 

[jess20k]

I prefer Le Cellier. I like the food better there. We have also always had wonderful service.