TransAtlantic Hitting very bad seas!

The fall trans atlantic usually crosses further south. So, it will be less likely to get into the nasty North Atlantic weather. But then it could meet a hurricane (or have to go around one).
I've been on three Disney cruises and spoke with the crew and they all said that as far a hurricanes go, it's actually safer at sea than on land because they can go around the hurricane or sail right inside the eye.
 
Photo from a Palo server.

View attachment 170775

He says.

" The water is crazy"

He is an expieranced Magic crew member.
Cool photo!

Maybe it's because this is #27 for me on DCL. Maybe it's because I'm from New England, but to me this is just ship movement that makes it a little challenging to walk in a straight line and can trigger seasickness bouts for those sensitive to it. It hasn't ruined my cruise by any means. For those who book 9D Oceanview on deck 1, however, be aware that they cover the little portholes as a precaution in rough seas.
Entertainment has been great and we are slated to see the refreshed and updated version of Twice Charmed!
 

I've done two WBTA cruises and both times where perfect plus I don't get seasick anyway. I know that the captain/crew do their best to avoid rough seas or bad weather if they can.
 
I've been on three Disney cruises and spoke with the crew and they all said that as far a hurricanes go, it's actually safer at sea than on land because they can go around the hurricane or sail right inside the eye.
Most times, I have been on a Panama crossing that had a west coast Pacific hurricane near Cabo San Lucas we sailed through the back end of it, on a tight schedule to Panama and called in Manzalino instead, then hit the tail end of Katrina. Normall round trip cruises they can avoid it, repos sometimes thry can't.
 
Most times, I have been on a Panama crossing that had a west coast Pacific hurricane near Cabo San Lucas we sailed through the back end of it, on a tight schedule to Panama and called in Manzalino instead, then hit the tail end of Katrina. Normall round trip cruises they can avoid it, repos sometimes thry can't.
Really? We've only ever done Caribbean cruises so it's good to know. We did discuss doing a transatlantic cruise but the idea of 4-5 days at sea, coupled with the risk of bad seas just doesn't appeal to me. I'd rather fly to Barcelona and do a European cruise.
 
Really? We've only ever done Caribbean cruises so it's good to know. We did discuss doing a transatlantic cruise but the idea of 4-5 days at sea, coupled with the risk of bad seas just doesn't appeal to me. I'd rather fly to Barcelona and do a European cruise.
I loved my Panama crossings we did them in 2005/2008, yes 4/5 days st sea makes you do stir crazy. I wouldn't do EBTAs wrong time, high chsnge bad seas, cold etc. Barcelona cruises are fantastic.
 
I'm definitely of the opinion rough seas can happen at any time and we've had some nutty weather/seas on the Bahamas/Caribbean sailings. I also think it's a matter of perspective as ten people can be on the same ship and opinions/experiences vary from "we almost sank" to "it was nothing at all". I don't mean to take away from anyone's experience but I've seen it happen and that's ok as people just have a different comfort and threshold. On our Norway/Iceland/Scotland sailing after we had left Iceland and were in the North Sea (as my memory recalls) we hit some pretty rough seas. The waves splashed up against our deck 2 window and it was pretty wild. My DH was LOVING it however walking around the ship there were several people sick, kids having to sit down as they were too ill to walk, people looking green, etc. We were totally fine and not bothered at all but it was a little challenging to walk.

I wouldn't let the itinerary scare anyone away if you had your heart set on it, as again, we've had some pretty choppy seas on our Bahama and Caribbean cruises as well. The ocean is pretty fierce and mother nature is amazing. Ships are made for this and that's what I say when I need to. :)

Heather
 
I love deck 2, and honestly if the seas are that bad there isn't going to be anywhere on the ship that isnt rocking and rolling.
But places elsewhere with fresh air, a view of the horizon, and sway rather then random short movement. But yes, all the ship is attached, it does flex in the water, like skyscrapers flex in the wind, if it didn't it would snap apart. It's not that one deck may not roll and roll, is other environmental issues, being closer to the sea, being closer to the engines, being enclosed, and less ironed out movement that you cannot judge.
 
Well, you can end up with a storm on any cruise. So, I am not sure I would base my decision of which cruise to pick on that. And as @kaseyC says, the southern route usually is less rough, so the fall TA should be the better choice for you.
I the EBTA takes a southern route next year, and then goes east. I think I would prefer the WB due to the time change anyway. I think the wb goes north this year. Maybe someday will find out the route of next years WB.
 
I'm definitely of the opinion rough seas can happen at any time and we've had some nutty weather/seas on the Bahamas/Caribbean sailings. I also think it's a matter of perspective as ten people can be on the same ship and opinions/experiences vary from "we almost sank" to "it was nothing at all". I don't mean to take away from anyone's experience but I've seen it happen and that's ok as people just have a different comfort and threshold. On our Norway/Iceland/Scotland sailing after we had left Iceland and were in the North Sea (as my memory recalls) we hit some pretty rough seas. The waves splashed up against our deck 2 window and it was pretty wild. My DH was LOVING it however walking around the ship there were several people sick, kids having to sit down as they were too ill to walk, people looking green, etc. We were totally fine and not bothered at all but it was a little challenging to walk.

I wouldn't let the itinerary scare anyone away if you had your heart set on it, as again, we've had some pretty choppy seas on our Bahama and Caribbean cruises as well. The ocean is pretty fierce and mother nature is amazing. Ships are made for this and that's what I say when I need to. :)

Heather
Agree, but to add our North Sea is rarely good, often rough with winds coming from the North, them blowing all the water into a funnel of the English Channel.
 
Agree, but to add our North Sea is rarely good, often rough with winds coming from the North, them blowing all the water into a funnel of the English Channel.
Indeed and we expected it to be that way and with that said - it really wasn't that bad IN OUR OPINION but if you asked several of my other cruisers they would have a different opinion :)
Heather
 
I'm definitely of the opinion rough seas can happen at any time and we've had some nutty weather/seas on the Bahamas/Caribbean sailings. I also think it's a matter of perspective as ten people can be on the same ship and opinions/experiences vary from "we almost sank" to "it was nothing at all". I don't mean to take away from anyone's experience but I've seen it happen and that's ok as people just have a different comfort and threshold. On our Norway/Iceland/Scotland sailing after we had left Iceland and were in the North Sea (as my memory recalls) we hit some pretty rough seas. The waves splashed up against our deck 2 window and it was pretty wild. My DH was LOVING it however walking around the ship there were several people sick, kids having to sit down as they were too ill to walk, people looking green, etc. We were totally fine and not bothered at all but it was a little challenging to walk.

I wouldn't let the itinerary scare anyone away if you had your heart set on it, as again, we've had some pretty choppy seas on our Bahama and Caribbean cruises as well. The ocean is pretty fierce and mother nature is amazing. Ships are made for this and that's what I say when I need to. :)

Heather
I agree, but with a TA theres lots of seas days vs a caribbean or european cruise so its definetely something to consider if your prone to sea sickness.
 
On our Eastern cruise in April on the Magic we got stuck with two really bad days at sea and oh boy that was not fun. We've always told people that it's no problem, you don't feel a thing, well now we realize we just got lucky with the seas we travelled on past cruises. We all had to take medicine and it was better but my ODD vomited. And i agree with others who say you feel it worse on the lower decks, some folks weren't able to stand up straight in AP during the evenings of rough seas. I hope the sea calms down for the folks on the Magic right now. Mother Nature kind of sucks this year.
 
Ok, I just checked and on our Norwegian Fjords cruise last year, we had winds of 40 knots as well. Yes, that is less than 42. And it was a moving quite a bit, but I did not consider it bad at all, just an adventure. I had no idea that this was already considered to be rough! We had an inside on deck 6 forward and slept like babies because of the motion. So, as @IBelieveInTheMagic said, it is just so subjective!
 
On our Eastern cruise in April on the Magic we got stuck with two really bad days at sea and oh boy that was not fun. We've always told people that it's no problem, you don't feel a thing, well now we realize we just got lucky with the seas we travelled on past cruises. We all had to take medicine and it was better but my ODD vomited. And i agree with others who say you feel it worse on the lower decks, some folks weren't able to stand up straight in AP during the evenings of rough seas. I hope the sea calms down for the folks on the Magic right now. Mother Nature kind of sucks this year.
Yes my daughter couldn't eat in AP in a storm, but had room service in deck 8 stateroom OK.
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!

























DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top