Also, as others have said before, "As long as you're happy with the trade, that's all that matters", and this saying still rings true. If you think that the other player is offering a fair amount than go for it!
But, in my opinion, I think you could get a lot more for the Black Candlestick, because as TikiKrissy said, "The candle is just too cool" lol. But ultimately, it's up to you.