TOP 5 & BOTTOM 5 places to eat...

[Erikarate]

My Top 5 places are:

1. California Grille
2. Citricos
3. Artist Point
4. Wolfgang Puck Cafe
5. LeCellier

Runners up are (sorry, even on my own thread, I find I can't stick to 5!!):

Whispering Canyon
50's Primetime (more for fun than food)
Jiko
'Ohana
Plaza Restaurant

Bottom 5 are:
1. Planet Hollywood
2. Tony's
3. Boma (sorry, I know I'm in the minority)
4. Pizza Planet
5. Rose and Crown

 

[cgcw]

Our top picks in no special order....

Ohana
Cape May Clam Bake
Cape May Character Breakfast
Flying Fish
LeCellier

Would not returns....

Bomas (we didn't care for it at all)
Wolfgang Pucks
Whispering Canyon Cafe

 

[KDawnLily]

I agree that Planet Hollywood is definitely on the bottom 5.

Last time we were there the attractions on the outside of the "globe" were on FIRE. No one in the restaurant knew. We only found out because as we exited the stairs leading up were blocked and a firefighter was coming up to take a look. A LITTLE unsafe.
The food was also extremely cold and we waited over 45 minutes to be seated, ordered and waited another hour before we were served.

The best place we have been to was the Crystal Palace for the Character Lunch. But I am biased... Tigger was there

others:
Chef Mickey's
Rainforest Cafe(Downtown Disney- haven't tried AK yet)
Ohana's
Capt. Jack's
Pecos Bill Cafe

Not So Good:
Mama Melrose(minority I know)
Pizza Planet
Rose and Crown
Columbia Harbour House

 

[eeyore0062]

TOP 5 full service:
Narcoosee's
Cape May Cafe-- dinner
50's Prime Time Cafe
1900 Park Faire-- breakfast
'Ohana-- dinner

Runners up are:
Mama Melrose
Le Cellier
Tempura Kiku
Kona Cafe
Fulton's
Planet Hollywood ( I know many don't like this place, but we have never had a bad meal, bad service or a wait to eat... I guess it is when you choose to go!)

Top 5 Counter Service:
Columbia Harbour House
Tusker's
Flametree BBQ
Pecos Bills
Cosmic Rays

BOTTOM 5:
Whispering Canyon Cafe-- dinner
Liberty Tree Tavern-- dinner
Chef Mickey's--- dinner
Boatwrights Dining Hall--- dinner
Rainforest Cafe

Bottom 5 Counter Service:
Yorkshire Fish House
Cantina San Angel
Pinocchios Village Haus
ABC Commissary
Liberty Inn


Places I am afraid to try:
Sci Fi Dine In

 

[Eeyore2U]

Top 5

Shula's
'Ohana
Brown Derby
Le Cellier
ESPN

Bottom

PH
RFC
Alfredo's
Chinese Counter Service
Wolfgang Puck's Upstairs

 

[dancechick99]

We have a ps for Rose and Crown in August. What did you not like about it? Now Im worried.

 

[dznyntnh]

Favorites:

Alfredo's
Sci-Fi Dine In
Grand Floridian Cafe
Cinderella's Royal Table
Boatwrights
House of Blues

I haven't had many dining disasters at Disney but I do refuse to return to the 50's Prime Time and Rainforest Cafe.

 

[mrslane]

Top 5

California Grille
Kimonos
Rose and Crown
Wolf Gang Puck's (outside, mid-level service)
Japan's lounge for sushi

Worst 5

Sci Fi
China's counter service
Morocco's sit down restaurant

 

[jimmalru80]

Top 5:
1) Teppanyaki
2) Kona Cafe
3) Le Cellier
4) Narcoosees
5) Marrakesh

Less Than Great:
1) Garden Grill
2) Brown Derby
3) Columbia Harbor House
4) Sci Fi
5) Coral Reef

 

[Erikarate]

dancechick-
I have found that everyone has their own opinion about a restaurant. What may be my worst restaurant is someone elses favorite and vice versa...So if something interests you...try it for yourself.

What I didn't like about Rose and Crown was that the fish and chips were soggy and greasy. I was very disappointed. DH also wasn't thrilled with his prime rib w/ yorkshire pudding. He says it wasn't horrible, but we'd rather go to Le Cellier...Our waitress was trying hard, but she made some errors that put a damper on our overall experience.

 

[Safari Steve]

Top 5:
Restaurant Akershus, Norway, Epcot
50s Prime Time Cafe, Studios
Flame Tree BBQ, DAK
Garden Grille, The Land, Epcot
Wolfgang Puck Express

Bottom 5:
World-Wide McDonalds, Osceola Pkwy near the All-Star resorts
McDonalds, Downtown Disney
Fairfax Fries, Studios
McDonalds Fry Cart, MK
Refreshment Port (featuring McDonalds fries and chicken nuggets), Epcot

 

[ugadog99]

Top 5 (no order)

1. Boma
2. Chef Mickey's (I know, I know so many of you don't like it!)
3. Narcoossee's (never can spell this right!)
4. Le Cellier
5. 'Ohana
6. Princess Storybook (yeah, it's supposed to be 5, but..)


Bottom 5

1. Hollywood and Vine
2. Hollywood and Vine
3. Hollywood and Vine
4. Hollywood and Vine
5. Cindy's (Sorry, we just didn't like it.)

 

[Planogirl]

Top five for me:
Boma
Cape May
Akershus
Columbia Harbour House
Hollywood & Vine

No bottom five, that's no fun!

 

[Minniespal]

Top Five

1. Liberty Tree Tavern
2. Cinderella's Royal Table
3. Hollywood Brown Derby
4. Victoria and Albert's
5. Chef Mickey's


Bottom Five

1. Alfredos
2. Tangerine Cafe
3. Pinochios's Haus
4. Cap 'n' Jacks
5. Columbia Harbour House

 

[Uncleromulus]

Top 5:
V&A
Citrico's
Jiko
Narcoossee's
California Grill

Bottom 5:
Fultons
Whispering Canyon
Liberty Tree Tavern
Rainforest Cafe
ESPN Club

 

[Terk-1]

My rankings would be:

Top:
Crystal Palace
Cindy's
1900 Park Fare
Tusker House
Concourse Steakhouse
Spoodle's
Le Cellier
Rose & Crown

Bottom:
Chef Mickey's
Rainforest Cafe

 

[Mickeyluver37]

Originally posted by Safari Steve

Bottom 5:
World-Wide McDonalds, Osceola Pkwy near the All-Star resorts
McDonalds, Downtown Disney
Fairfax Fries, Studios
McDonalds Fry Cart, MK
Refreshment Port (featuring McDonalds fries and chicken nuggets), Epcot [/B]

I am LMAO at this one. However, besides being overpriced, I thought the WDW McDonalds were fine. Now, the one in Orlando near Universal....."The World's Largest Playplace McDonalds" was the dirtiest most disgusting fast food place I've ever been in. We went because of the Playplace, but I then refused to let my kids set foot in that part.

 

[brutus]

I love reading the "rating type" threads. However, I have found, when it comes to places to eat, the most popular, are going to appear in the top & bottom lists.

Take Chef Mickey's & WCC. Both these are very popular dining places. But both will be on most lists...either top or bottom.

I say, go and experience for yourself!

 

[brutus]

so......

Here are my top 5....

'Ohana
Flying Fish
Citricos
WCC
V&A

Bottom....

Well, I'll put just one here that we won't go back to anytime soon...


Alfredos

 

[jx3smom]

My top five are:

1. Narcoosee
2. Flying Fish
3. Cape May
4. Artist Pt.
5. Wolfgang Puck

Bottom five are:

1. Pizza Planet-never ever again
2. Hollywood and Vine
3. Planet Hollywood
4. Big River
5. Columbia House