Tonys Town Square MK v Alfredos's EPCOT

[magicmouse2]

Where would you go for the best Italian lunch ??
Afredos or Tony's

Considering food and atmosphere.

 

[MHopkins2]

I've never eaten at Alfredo's, but enjoyed my lunch last March at Tony's. The fried cheese is really good if you're into (relatively mild) goat cheese - it was a wonderful change of pace from plain old mozzarella sticks. It's also a fairly restful spot, out of the MK bustle. Keep in mind if you like a "tasty beverage" with your lunch that Tony's, like all MK eateries, serves no alcohol.

 

[Micca]

Both of these locations are controversial. I haven't eaten at Tony's, but we've been dining at 'Fredo's since Epcot opened. It's an absolute MUST for us.

 

[dvcfamily41801]

We prefer Tony's Town Square over Alfredo's. We had a terrible experience at Alfredo's in December. But it could have just been it was a rainy night and it was super super crowded, but the food was just not that great, and it was dinner. We did have lunch at Tony's when it was the Pooh lunch while Crystal Palace was closed. We really enjoyed that.

 

[MickeyisanNDfan]

I have never eaten at Tony's but you couldn't pay me to eat at Alfredo's again. We have been a couple of times tried really hard to like it and just can't.

 

[leighe]

Isn't it funny how opinons differ? DH and I love Alfredo's. We eat there every trip. I've never been to Tony's so I can't compare.

 

[vellamint]

Alfredos = the most expensive and disgusting meal we had
Tonys = giving it a shot this time around

 

[webray]

Alfredo's has the best Italian.

Tony's is mediocre at best...we wouldn't return there.

 

[cjsmith]

The food at Alfredo's is better than Tony's. Tony's reminds me of pizzeria food at best. My husband doesn't like Alfredo's only because he feels it's too crowded for dinner, but he'll eat lunch there for the kids sake.