Tony's or Mama Melrose's?

[Smiling Cheshire Cat]

Less than a month until ADR's. Does anyone have opinions about these 2 restaurants. Their menus look a little similar. DS is a fan of Italian food and we are definitely going to Tutto's.

Are either of these restaurants good? And does anyone know if you can order the flatbreads at Tony's for dinner?

Thanks-

 

[BigEeyore]

We hated Tony's - nothing much good to say about it, other than nice atmosphere. Never tried Mama Melrose!

 

[innoculation]

Mama Melrose is a fantastic restaurant! Great service, food is good, and a different atmosphere than others we have ben to.

 

[mjpeter]

I've never tried Tony's, but we had a great dinner at Mama Melrose! We'll be there Oct 29th for the Fantasmic package.

 

[Steamboat Girlie]

We loved Mama Melrose!
We are trying Tony's next month. I have heard mixed review about it, but we want to try it! We'll let you know.

 

[Dawn68PA]

Never been to Mama's but we loved Tony's! The place was half empty, our waiter was very nice and the food was yummy.

 

[MHSweb79]

To further confuse you, we had a fabulous dinner at Tony's and on the same trip had terrible food and extremely slow service at Mama Melrose. MM was so bad I'll never go back. Tony's, on the other hand, was our 2nd favorite meal (leCellier took first place).
So I would say just book whichever is more convenient for your schedule and take your chances.

 

[rsimon]

Less than a month until ADR's. Does anyone have opinions about these 2 restaurants. Their menus look a little similar. DS is a fan of Italian food and we are definitely going to Tutto's.

Are either of these restaurants good? And does anyone know if you can order the flatbreads at Tony's for dinner?

Thanks-

We REALLY didn't like Tony's but we LIKE Mama's a lot and eat there every trip at least once and sometimes more. They have good flat breads and other dishes.