I've only been to Narcoossees and Yachtsman...but they were both nice. The food was good, service at Yachtsman was ok. Service was better for us at Narcoossees... I am a filet addict and we actually liked Le Cellier the best! Never been to Jiko..sorry. I don't know that we'll do Yachtsman again. It was just more comfortable at Narcoossees...location was nice, great view!!