Thinking of Disney Cruise for 2009 or 2010

In Luv with Disney

DIS Veteran
Joined
May 4, 2004
Messages
1,759
Hi, all! My family and I are going on a Bahamas/Florida Cruise from NY on Norwegian in 2 months...just booked it last week and got an AWESOME deal! 7 days, 6 nights...$2000 for 4 of us, INCLUSIVE of all taxes and port fees! :cheer2:

That being said, it's not Disney and I hear such WONDERFUL things about DCL! I just can't justify the cost right now...I priced the same week on DCl for a 7 night cruise and it was $4300 plus $1000 for airfare. $5300! That's almost 3 times what I'm paying on Norwegian! :scared1:

My question is this...how do you all justify the price difference to cruise with DCL rather than other comparable cruise lines? Is it really worth it? And what about discounts...HOW DO YOU GET THE BEST DEAL???:confused:
 
I'm willing to pay a little more for Disney, but certainly not double. I booked a 7-night cruise out of San Juan on Adventure of the Seas (RCI) during my son's spring break next month. A 7-night cruise on Disney would've cost twice as much.

To get a good price on DCL - you need to book WAY in advance, and choose a time when school kids aren't on vacation. I booked the Nov. 28-Dec. 6, 2009 western cruise. That's the week after Thanksgiving, and a fairly inexpensive time to cruise - as Disney prices go.

**Edited to add - you got an awesome deal on NCL because it's after the final payment date for that cruise, and NCL wants to fill the ship. That can happen on Disney, too - but not as often.
 
I am a DVC member, and I am paying with points. The best bang for my points is the 7-day cruise. Anything more than that, I would pay points and cash. But this really offsets paying all in cash. :goodvibes
 
Hi, all! My family and I are going on a Bahamas/Florida Cruise from NY on Norwegian in 2 months...just booked it last week and got an AWESOME deal! 7 days, 6 nights...$2000 for 4 of us, INCLUSIVE of all taxes and port fees! :cheer2:

That being said, it's not Disney and I hear such WONDERFUL things about DCL! I just can't justify the cost right now...I priced the same week on DCl for a 7 night cruise and it was $4300 plus $1000 for airfare. $5300! That's almost 3 times what I'm paying on Norwegian! :scared1:

My question is this...how do you all justify the price difference to cruise with DCL rather than other comparable cruise lines? Is it really worth it? And what about discounts...HOW DO YOU GET THE BEST DEAL???:confused:

Hi Kim. Yeah, Disney's prices kill me!! But, I LOVE their cruise. Of course, I have nothing to compare it to, but we have had 2 wonderful cruises on Disney. People who have cruised on other lines have said they've been disappointed, so I'm nervous to try another line.

To get the best price on Disney, you need to book very early - preferably as soon as the new pricing comes out. We booked the Mediterranean cruise the first day it was available. As the day went on, I watched the price creep up and up - and thats on the same day!! I just booked the Thanksgiving week 09 cruise a couple of months ago. The pricing stayed the same for about 2 months and then jumped about $600 - and thats 20 months out!! I think Disney's prices are lowest in January, but that means pulling the kids out of school which I hate doing.

To get a deal on the Disney ship, look for the category 12 discount that is sometimes offered 2 -3 months before sailing. Its always a "guaranteed" room - meaning that you don't pick your rooms; its assigned as cruise time gets closer. There are so few of these cat 12 rooms, that you're likely to get upgraded. We got lucky on our Mediterranean cruise and were upgraded from a cat 12 to a cat 9 (exterior room with large porthole). Most other folks were upgraded, but still ended up with an interior room. We had originally booked a balcony stateroom and had switched to the category 12 when we saw the huge discount in price - saved us a ton of money!

One other thing - while on your Disney cruise, you can book another cruise at a 10% discount. You can book a "dummy" date and then move your 10% to any cruise at any time. The 10% helps! Also, I never pay extra for the insurance (which I may regret one day) or the transportation. You can get other transportation to the port for less money. Those things together will save you $500 for a family of 4.

Good luck! Would love to hear how the Norwegian cruise goes!

Jodie
 
Hi Kim. Yeah, Disney's prices kill me!! But, I LOVE their cruise. Of course, I have nothing to compare it to, but we have had 2 wonderful cruises on Disney. People who have cruised on other lines have said they've been disappointed, so I'm nervous to try another line.

To get the best price on Disney, you need to book very early - preferably as soon as the new pricing comes out. We booked the Mediterranean cruise the first day it was available. As the day went on, I watched the price creep up and up - and thats on the same day!! I just booked the Thanksgiving week 09 cruise a couple of months ago. The pricing stayed the same for about 2 months and then jumped about $600 - and thats 20 months out!! I think Disney's prices are lowest in January, but that means pulling the kids out of school which I hate doing.

To get a deal on the Disney ship, look for the category 12 discount that is sometimes offered 2 -3 months before sailing. Its always a "guaranteed" room - meaning that you don't pick your rooms; its assigned as cruise time gets closer. There are so few of these cat 12 rooms, that you're likely to get upgraded. We got lucky on our Mediterranean cruise and were upgraded from a cat 12 to a cat 9 (exterior room with large porthole). Most other folks were upgraded, but still ended up with an interior room. We had originally booked a balcony stateroom and had switched to the category 12 when we saw the huge discount in price - saved us a ton of money!

One other thing - while on your Disney cruise, you can book another cruise at a 10% discount. You can book a "dummy" date and then move your 10% to any cruise at any time. The 10% helps! Also, I never pay extra for the insurance (which I may regret one day) or the transportation. You can get other transportation to the port for less money. Those things together will save you $500 for a family of 4.

Good luck! Would love to hear how the Norwegian cruise goes!

Jodie

Jodie, thank you SO much for your post!!!!!!!! It really gave me a lot to think about.

When do the new cruises come out? 2 years in advance? Is there an exact day they release them? What do you think is the better deal...booking really far in advance or booking the cat 12 guarantee 2-3 months out?
 
Jodie, thank you SO much for your post!!!!!!!! It really gave me a lot to think about.

When do the new cruises come out? 2 years in advance? Is there an exact day they release them? What do you think is the better deal...booking really far in advance or booking the cat 12 guarantee 2-3 months out?

The 2009 trips were released this past December, so I'm guessing it will be around that time when 2010 is released. The best thing to do is call Disney Cruise Line this Fall and ask them when the 2010 itinerary will be released. Also, there is usually a thread on this message board with itinerary rumors and expected release dates, etc - kind of fun to speculate what the itinerary will be.

If I were you, I would pick a cruise as soon as they're released. If your schedule is flexible, then I would periodically check for the category 12 discounts. I have noticed lately that some cruises already have category 12 pricing built in - meaning that its not added later as a sale fare.

How many are in your family?

There are also "secret porthole rooms" which are priced as a category 10 (inside) but are actually outside rooms with an obstructed view. Its nice to get the cheaper fare if you don't mind the obstruction. For more info on that, check www.mousesavers.com.

You might also want to check rates in September. I seem to remember them being low as well. Good luck!

Jodie
 
We will be taking our 2nd DCL cruise on 1/31/09.
The special Eastern with St. Croix.
My sister-in-law booked it for us when her and DH were on the Wonder for a 3 nighter.
She saved us the 10%, got us $100 stateroom credit, then switched it to her cruise travel agent for another $200 stateroom credit for a total of $300 to spend! So don't forget to transfer your reservation to your travel agent!

Now the price of the cruise has gone up another $800+ !!

We will definetely rebook while on this cruise in February!
Even if we don't no for sure when we'll cruise.. we'll have a 10% off booking out there for us!
Hoping my DH will plan on cruising annually!
He absolutely LOVED the 2 week panama canal cruise we took in 2005!

I'm a very frugal person... so knowing all the ways to save means a lot to me!! Happy Savings & Cruising Everyone!! :yay:
 
My DH and I have been looking at a Med cruise through RCI as well.. it is significantly lower in price than Disney and we were so tempted to go... but since the rumors of 2010 going to Med has been circulating, we will just wait and PAY the extra cost to cruise with Disney.. the MAIN reason is my DD4 going on 5. princess: She absolutely loved being on the Disney cruise. The characters/Princesses in particular got to know her by name and whenever they would meet in the hallway, they would call her by name and her eyes just lit up. It is the most amazing thing ever.. that big grin on my DD's face is PRICELESS. Whatever amount of money we spend cruising with disney, is well worth it.
 
Jodie, thank you SO much for your post!!!!!!!! It really gave me a lot to think about.

When do the new cruises come out? 2 years in advance? Is there an exact day they release them? What do you think is the better deal...booking really far in advance or booking the cat 12 guarantee 2-3 months out?

I believe the 2010 itineraries are due to be released 10/7 next month. I would recommend booking as early as possible. DCL's ships usually sail full, if they end up with cabins still open close to sailing, they will release special Florida resident rates or sometimes military rates. Very rarely does the price go down for the general public.

Good luck - have fun planning!
 
...how do you all justify the price difference to cruise with DCL rather than other comparable cruise lines?


Because we had to do it .... at least once. Now I have 1 more cruise line to compare other cruise lines with. We did our first Disney cruise this summer...and, yes, the price almost killed us, BUT, we had a great time and it was worth it. (I planned for years for this cruise...using my reward dollars from my Disney Visa to pay for my son's part of the cruise.) Will we cruise Disney again? Not likely, but not because it wasn't a great cruise...because of the price (& time of year we have to go).

I say do at least 1....you won't be disappointed....we weren't! ;) (my trip report is linked in my sig if you are interested in reading about our 4 day double dip)
 
Thank you all so much. DH is still undecided if the premium is worth it. We went on a cruise in April (NCL...NY to Port Canaveral, Nassau and Grand Bahama). I LOVED it! Him? Not so much...he thought it was EH. :confused3 Now that he sees DCL priced so much higher, not sure he will give in. I'm still trying to school him though!!!!! :teacher:
 
We have been on Disney Cruise Line, Royal Caribbean, Princess and most recently, Norwegian.
I would say that we had great experiences on all of these lines, but they are not comparable.
We booked NCL because of the very low price close to sailing date. We paid @ $2400 for 2 cabins (2 people in each cabin) on the Easter sailing of the Norwegian Sun.
The advice a friend gave me before going on NCL was to keep our expectations low. That was the best advice we ever received before going on a cruise. Because our expectations were low, we were pleasantly surprised and had a great time despite the differences in quality on the NCL cruise when compared to all of the others. We like to take 2 to 3 vacations per year.....so for us ....price matters a lot.
Our attitude is that there is no such thing as a bad cruise. They are all different experiences.
We would book NCL again....but only for the "right price" and one like yours, that is a significant price savings compared to other lines.

BTW, we have a Disney Land/ Sea package booked the first week of November that we got an incredible deal on. When I check the other cruise lines for that same week, the prices are even lower than what we paid for the Disney cruise. But it is all relative. Prices right now seem to be down as we get close to sailing because with this economy....folks cut back on travel.

So....my advice is to keep your expectations in line. The NCL ships are beautiful, and some are new and there is still a lot to do. But, the experience is very different from Disney. Enjoy your cruise and as a fellow bargain hunter....what a deal!
 
We use our DVC points also.

But we will use them for soemthing else after our kids no longer sail with us.
and Cruise with other cruise lines.

But with the kids it give us soem freedom and the kids soem extra fun.
 
I forgot to mention.... it's not only important to know how to save and get the best deal when booking a DCL cruise...it's important to remember that you are not just cruising... you are being given the gift of Disney Magic. All the wonderful little special touches that ONLY Disney can do and will do for you and your family.

I remember at the end of our cruise, I filled out a questionnaire asking if any cast member made our vacation any more special. I was able to write a resounding YES! I was continuously surprised at the little things they did for us that made our cruise unbelievable.

From the moment you check in at the terminal and step onto that beautiful ship, you are treated special! They announce each family seperately as they board. They smile and help you with every question, no matter how simple or complex.

The size of the cabins, quality of the food and entertainment just can't be compared to other cruise lines....it all includes pixie dust. Tinker bell just doesn't visit the other cruise lines!

:wizard: ... pirate: (pirate night!)
And... as an exta special touch of magic... don't forget that DCL is the ONLY ship that is allowed to shoot off fireworks. On the open ocean... that is truely magical!

I don't believe we will ever cruise on a different cruise line. I would be too sad about missing all of the Disney magic! We're looking forward to seeing the two new ships!

Hope you all find a way to experience DCL!
 
Something I cannot stress enough is the time of year you go.

We are actually looking into the off seasons, somewhere between September and January.

We compared prices of basically the exact same cruise and this is what we found. What we found was basically a difference of $600.

Now, depending on how many people you have in your party and your preferences, you can add on the cost of free beverages. For us, on a different cruise line, that would add about $120-150. So, that brings us down to only about a $500 difference.

That is much more doable than double or triple, wouldn't you say, especially for a bigger room, Disney touches, and from what I have heard, a better private island.
 
I will tell you that we were on Royal Caribbean's Mariner of the Seas, which sails out of Port Canaveral the same day as the Wonder. Having been on the Wonder (and the Magic), it was heartbreaking to see the Wonder sail away and know we weren't on it.

Royal Caribbean was not our thing.

The Disney terminal is cool, relaxing, and filled with friendly faces and entertainment.

The RCI terminal? I swear, there were people telling us to move on when we had just come up from the escalators. We weren't standing in anyone's way (we were off to the side), but had to wait on my FIL who was stopped and frisked. We couldn't wait near security because they told us to "move on!" too. We just always felt we were in someone's way in the terminal.

On Disney, it is such a treat to board the ship. It really does feel special.

On RCI, our entrance onto the ship consisted of a sweaty, tired terminal agent looking at our key cards and telling us to enter the ship "that way." We walked onto the ship with no one to greet us or welcome us on board. The first people we ran into were other confused cruisers trying to figure out what areas were open and where to go to lunch. We did see a crew member, but he was only there to guard the entry to the staterooms and barked "1 o'clock!" as in the rooms would be ready at one. The very next crew we ran into hawked soda cards. No "hello". No "welcome aboard." Just "soda cards!"

On Disney, my wife likes to have bartenders surprise her with a drink. We find most bartenders have a special drink that only he or she "knows how to make." The bartenders on Disney always meet this as a happy and welcome challenge. On RCI when my wife told the bartenders to make her their specialties, she got a rude "this is what we serve" as they pointed to the menus.

I could go on.

I'd gladly have given up my 7-day on Mariner for a 4-day on the Wonder. Incidentally, we're paying more for our 4-day on the Wonder in April 2009 than we did for our August 7-day on the Mariner. But that's ok with both of us.
 
Was wondering if the OP decided to go on a Disney Cruise.

I am looking at going on a Disney Cruise in June 2012 for my 39th Birthday with my Mom (girls only!) and have been trying to find out all the ins and outs of going on a Disney Cruise. I have noticed that booking early seems to be the key so I was wondering when the rates for 2012 will possibly be available. I did a search and this thread popped up. I noticed that there seems to be a 2yr theme going on to when the rates are released. I guess I should start paying attention starting this October.

I told a friend that I was going to take a cruise with my Mom on DCL and she tried to warn me that there would be a bunch of kids on there and that it wouldn't be that fun for just adults. I said that there is an adult only pool and bars but she just brushed it off with "Yeah, there are a couple but...".

Just leave me alone and let me be excited.
 
Subi ^ doesn't have kids...they are a 'couple' only and consistently go on Disney cruises.

They love it and don't seem to feel overwhelmed with kids everywhere...because honestly...they really do keep the kids occupied.

It's a BIG ship....lots to do. Don't let your friend worry you about the kids...you can escape them.....(we did, and we took a 9yr old WITH us! :laughing: )
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!





-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom