I have taken the Alaska
ABD (back in 2009) and absolutely totally LOVED it! It was my second trip to Alaska (the first was a Princess cruisetour). And I have to say, as much as I loved my cruisetour, the Alaska ABD was even better. They've changed the itinerary since then (No time in Fairbanks, but more time in Anchorage). Although I loved Fairbanks, and am sad it's gone, the additions they made in Anchorage *more* than make up for it. I'm actually considering taking this ABD again (if I could afford to do 2 ABD's in a year, I'd so do this one as the second! But there's so many new places to go!)
You go further into the "real" Alaska than a cruise does. The ports in the Inland passage are cute, but they don't show you the majesty that is inland Alaska! The Kenai Peninsula (absofrickinlutely amazing!), Turnagain Arm, Denali National Park and Mt Denali (spectacular!), it all leaves Juneau, Ketchikan, and Skagway in the dust. If you loved Cowboys & Canyons (my favorite ABD until recently) I think you'll love the Alaska ABD, too.
Just for some perspective, at the end of the trip (post-day on my own) I tripped and fell and sliced my head open on a wooden deck step. Staples in my scalp, missed my flight. And yet, it was just a minor blip, and in NO WAY diminished my love of this trip.
In case you couldn't tell, I highly recommend this trip. I happen to think that Alaska is one of the most beautiful places in the World. And ABD does a really nice job of showing it to you.
Sayhello