treesinger
<font color=blue>Runs in fear from the <font color
- Joined
- Feb 9, 2002
- Messages
- 1,774
The Republican position on bi-lingual programs, IIRC, is to be against those programs that are meant to perpetuate NOT learning and do NOT emphasize needing to learn the language that a huge majority of the country speaks.
Language can be a huge barrier and can be lifesaving. This winter, there was a fire in Philadelphia. The family only spoke Spanish. No one on the fire team spoke Spanish so they didn't understand that there were more children still inside.
Wanting English to be the national language is NOT about elitism, snobbism or disrespect of any person's culture. It's about consistency, safety and community. Those that can not communicate with safety officials endanger themselves and their families. Those that do not speak English separate themsleves from a majority of the US population by default.
Now, that said, I have NOTHING wrong with businesses that conduct themsleves in other languages only, press 2 for Spanish, or otherwise pander to people who only speak a different language. Private enterprise is private. However, when it comes to government functions and services, I believe they should only be presented in English unless the department, as a rule, MUST have multi-lingual support. (say, department of hispanic affairs)
Language can be a huge barrier and can be lifesaving. This winter, there was a fire in Philadelphia. The family only spoke Spanish. No one on the fire team spoke Spanish so they didn't understand that there were more children still inside.
Wanting English to be the national language is NOT about elitism, snobbism or disrespect of any person's culture. It's about consistency, safety and community. Those that can not communicate with safety officials endanger themselves and their families. Those that do not speak English separate themsleves from a majority of the US population by default.
Now, that said, I have NOTHING wrong with businesses that conduct themsleves in other languages only, press 2 for Spanish, or otherwise pander to people who only speak a different language. Private enterprise is private. However, when it comes to government functions and services, I believe they should only be presented in English unless the department, as a rule, MUST have multi-lingual support. (say, department of hispanic affairs)