Hi All!
Just got back from Poly concierge less than 2 days ago, and I must say I won't choose that one again. I can see why some DISers love it and feel at home there, it just isn't for me.
Background: we usually stay at GF concierge (my dh and 2 dd's) I go crazy planning out what we can do and see while we are there, as kids are still very little. I must say that I fell in love with GF on my 1st trip, and even more when I broke my elbow last year and ther bent over backwards to help us enjoy our stay. My oldest is autistic, so convenience is key for us.
This year, I booked the trip 2 weeks in advance. It was MY 3 kids (6,5,and 3) and I with my best friend and her 16mo. We needed Deluxe to all fit in 1 room. I was able to get 5 nites at Poly garden view. I wish I either stuck with that or tried to switch to GF. Over 2 weeks I was able to upgrade nites 2-5 to Poly concierge. I made all the ADRs and event reservations myself, even though I emailed poly concierge, I never heard from them. We arrived at Poly early (like 10am) and checked in at main registration. At that point I was able to upgrade to Poly concierge for the entire stay (why I couldn't 16 hours earlier is still a mystery to me) We missed the opportunity to use the check in feature of concierge service, but no biggie.
The room was not ready for us until almost 4:45, the CM told me the people before us "wouldn't leave". We hung out at the pool (with all of our carry-ons) and they said they would call us on my cell. They didn't, and the room was ready when I went back to check again. No prob, but that made us late for dinner at Jiko, with 4 kids under 6 who were tired and hungry.
We had room 1504, and it was nice. Crowded with our gang, but had a fantastic MK view and patio. Being on the monorail was wonderful and having the pools close, but not too close was great as well.
Lounge was fine, although never enough kids seats. Food offering was great for us, but my friend's kid wouldn't eat anything there , so she ended up ordering room service for him. When my kids saw the Mickey Pancakes, I had to order for them as well (so much for the cost benefit of eating bfast in the lounge). Chef Dick was great, and the lounge was always clean and staff friendly.
Mousekeeping was a big problem. Never got any of those special touches like towel creatures or chocolates. We left the room by 9:45 or 10 every day, and when we got back to put the little boys for a nap (1:30ish) the room wasn't done the first day, so on days 2-5 I requested they do it each time we left, but it never happened. Each day, they came to service the room when the kids were asleep, and then returned for turndown service when they were still asleep (4ish)--so we never really got any real room cleaning. With 2 kids in diapers it started getting yucky. There was sand from our beautiful beach on the carpet, overflowing trash constantly, etc. I am the type who needs to make the bed and tidy before walking out the door, so it drove me nuts. Timing was the problem, again not their fault with all the rooms to clean, but to show up after 1pm for cleaning, and before 5 for turndown at a deluxe resort in a concierge building was a bit annoying.
The concierge CMs were pleasant and helpful mostly, but I really only needed them for 2 dining reservations.
We ended up using taxis rather than buses to get from Poly to places not on the monorail. It was hard to get them to call us a cab. The front staff NEVER opened a cab door for us (not a princess, but we WERE juggling 4 kids) But I still tipped EVERYONE...from the beginning to the end of the trip.
My kids loved the Neverland Club (more than at GFs, although they are one yr older now) They adored the pool. It was a bit hard for me to watch my 3 kids simultaneuosly, but the guard staff were nice.
We heard complaints at Kona (Fathers Day bfast) that "not one waitstaff smiled at them the whole meal". But we had a nice server, and that group was lingering over bfast when the place was trying to switch to lunch (we were first seated for lunch).
It was crowded and HOT in the parks. We ended up only going to MK and AK the kids. Thank goodness we didn't buy length of stay passes! Never been in June before, but we went in August and it was less crowded. Never saw the Year of a Million Dream Team.

I don't think I would choose June again, but it was a last minute trip. It never rained once in 6 days.
All in all -a great trip. My kids had fun. My pal and I had loads of laughs, and it IS WDW afterall. Just wanted to give my 2 cents on Poly concierge. After walking around the property, I only saw a few 1st floor rooms that I would say were a bad spot. If I stay there again, it would be 3rd floor, most any building.
But GF is my happy place. Just my own thing I guess.
