Hey all! Just back from the GF yesterday. We had such a wonderful time, even with my cranky DD15. I think I may do a trip report just so I can remember all the lovely details (and post some great pics). It went by way too fast.
We stayed in Conch Key in room 7303 (which we loved for the quiet and convenience to the boats - but if you want quiet, stay more toward the middle of the building as we were next to the exit doors and heard them slam repeatedly). It had a nice view of the marina and monorail. We also rented the cabana on two occasions and I HIGHLY recommend this. It was fabulous. You have your own helper all day and prompt service from the bar and private dining. We felt like kings.
1900 Park Fair with Cinderella and the step sisters was very entertaining and the food was great! My DD12 and DD6 also loved the Alice in Wonderland Tea. I had tea myself (blissfully alone!) in the tea room. For those mom's out there who can swing the alone time, this was priceless.
To be fair, there were some negatives. The hotel is beautiful as it was modeled after the Hotel Del Coronado in San Diego. However, having stayed in the Hotel Del, I have to say the GF wasn't as luxurious. I did expect all those small things that usually come with luxury hotels like down comforters and pillows and well insulated walls (we could actually hear our upstairs neighbors peeing in their toilet - ew!). We could also hear verbatim conversations in the rooms surrounding us. Also, even though there was a flat screen TV, there were no movie stations or pay per view options which would have been nice after long days in the parks.
Private dining was very convenient and DD15 used it a few times when I let her hole up in the room. But the food quality is the same as Gasparillas. We ordered breakfast and my husband's grand slam was exactly the same as what he'd ordered in Gaspies. We were surprised by this considering Gasparilla's cost us about $25 for the family and the private dining was $100. Just FYI.
A word on Narcoossee's (don't throw things, please!) - we were very disappointed. Our meal took two hours. And everything was greasy. My husband ordered the filet and it tasted like the gas flames it was cooked on. I ordered the tilefish and it was greasy and tasted like it was reheated. We would have sent it all back, but we were so starving by that point, we didn't want to wait any longer. Perhaps we were there on an off night (the service was bad, too), but it was definitely not worth the $200 we spent.
As far as transportation, I would definitely recommend taxis to Animal Kingdom and Downtown Disney. We did this and it was smooth sailing. The monorail to Magic Kingdom and Epcot was a snap, of course. We also took the boat over to the Polynesian for breakfast and the Neverland Club and we often took the boat from the MK to the GF since the launch was right outside our building. Very convenient and a beautiful ride.
While there were some disappointments, overall we had a wonderful stay. I would recommend everyone who really wants to try this resort to definitely do so even though we found there wasn't enough luxury to meet the cost.
Tracy