We arrived at Raglan Road about 10 minutes ahead of our ADR time (which was noon) and found the restaurant surprisingly empty. Maybe it was because Downtown Disney is not as busy as the parks and it was kind of early. But we were in the restaurant until at least 1 pm and the entire time we saw probably only five parties in the restaurant.
We had tried Raglan Road on an earlier trip a few years ago and we hadn't had a good experience that time. It had been the last dinner of our first trip together (a
free dining trip) on the 7th day. This was before GF had been treated for sleep apnea and plantar faciitis (a foot problem) so she was quite miserable by the end of the trip and wanted to skip our last dinner. I was tired too, but I wanted to have that last dinner and so we went. We had a late ADR and ended up being late for it--so late that the kitchen had technically stopped serving. Our server didn't seem very happy to have to deal with us and our food was luke-warm and not good. GF even got the bread and butter pudding to go and didn't enjoy it when she ate it the next day.
So we didn't have great aspirations for this meal, but we also figured there was no where to go but up!
We ordered as follows:
Goatstown salad10.95
Soup4.95
Lobster Club13.95
Port Burger11.50
Dundons Delight7.99
Bread and butter pudding7.99
Iced tea2.5
Iced tea2.5
Tax4.06
Total66.39 2 credits
Tip12.01
The appetizer menu had only three appetizers that were designed for one person--all of the others could be chosen on the DXDP only by using two people's appetizer credit. The shareable appetizers were all meat which meant that they weren't something GF and I were about to share. So we were limited in our choices. There was soup of the day, the Goatstown salad, and I'm drawing a blank on the third one (I know it was seafood or meat).
We asked the server about the soup of the day and she said it was tomato gin soup. That sounded good to me, but given my earlier stomach problems I was worried it would trigger more acid reflux symptoms given the alcohol and acidity of the tomato. The Goatstown salad didn't sound very good to me (I think I may have even had it as an appetizer the last time we ate here), but it was my only option. GF decided to go for the soup and offered to let me have some (hence guaranteeing that she got to eat some of my salad).
Here are our appetizers:
You might be wondering why the tomato soup is green. We had the same question when it was served (by someone other than our server). We both tasted and thought "doesn't taste like tomato either"

. Then we discussed how perhaps it was made with green tomatoes. In any case, it was quite good and creamy--though, the complete lack of a gin taste should also have been a tip off.
I had a few more spoonfuls and GF was chowing down when the server came to check on us. She took one look at the soup and said, "What happened to tomato soup?" We said, "Uh, we thought this was the tomato--but we were wondering why it was green." I believe she said it was Colcannon soup--which apparently has ham in it. Oops--well it didn't taste like meat.
GF asked if there actually was any tomato soup since we were planning to share the soup and salad and the server said she'd check. Turned out that the tomato gin was the soup for dinner only so they hadn't made it yet. Didn't matter to GF, though, as she was quite enjoying the soup. She described it as a light thin cream of broccoli with a noticeable hint of butter.
My salad was fine. GF seemed to enjoy it more than me even though she usually doesn't enjoy goat cheese very much. I used to be more of a fan and she really hated the stuff, but somehow that changed recently and now she likes a lot of it and I'm more grossed out. Strange

She thought they selected a good goat cheese which was creamy and not too goaty and she liked the raspberry puree with it.
On to entrees. I had only one option--the portobello sandwich. And GF decided on the lobster club mostly just because it was something new and different. We got to pick one side along with our entrees. She chose roasted veggies and I chose potatoes.
GF descried the lobster club as "a little strange, but good." First of all she didnt think that it actually had lobster in it. She suspected it was 95-100% crab and that perhaps there was some lobster hidden in it; but all she could taste was crab (but high quality crab). The lobster was mixed with a little mayo and sandwiched between white toast and a little bit of crispy bacon and egg. The bacon was nice touch, but she couldnt taste egg. She described the bread as "like eating sryrofoam, but the flavor of dish was pretty good and made up for the bread.
She had the roasted veggies on the side which had mustard sauce and were sort of sweet from roasting. (I tried these and didn't really like them, but I think I was still having some sensitivity given my earlier stomach issues.) She liked them but couldn't eat much as she was getting full by then.
I had the portobella mushroom sandwich with cheese and tomato relish and got potatoes as my side. The potatoes usually come with chive mayo but I dont like mayo, so I asked if they were already mixed with the mayo. The server said no and I asked for them plain. As expected, plain potatoes are not all that appetizing, but I did choose it. The other sides just didn't sound good to me.
My portobella sandwich was good and I dont even like portobella that much. It was cooked well (barbecued maybe?) and the bun was very tasty and had caramelized onions on top. The cheese and tomato relish were very good as well. Still, I didnt love it. It was clearly a well done entrée, but I'm not sure it was for me. Of course, this was really only an hour or two after my bout of nausea so it might have been that I was just not in my normal state of appreciativeness of food at that moment.
And finally dessert. Here is a pic of the menu (which they bring to you on a big wooden slab):
Our server left it with us so we could read it and decide what to order, but she told us that technically they are supposed to hold it up in front of you while you read it. How weird! What if you are indecisive and need to study the menu for a bit?

In the end I chose the bread and butter pudding (despite GF's warning that she hadn't liked it that much when she tried it). The perfect dessert for GF would have been the Three Times a Berry--a panna cotta with berries--since panna cotta is her favorite dessert. But they were out of that one that day. Nothing else really sounded good to her so she randomly chose the Dundon's Delight--"Strawberry pavlova with vanilla pod ice cream. Served on a strawberry and champagne consoome."
GF didnt like her dessert. It came with two meringues which she is not a fan of given their sweetness. I tasted them also and the insides were kind of wet and smushy. GF said she's heard that that is how meringues are supposed to be, but I found it gross. I like my meringues very hard and very sweet. Along with the meringues was a scoop of garden variety vanilla ice cream. She described the raspberry mint champagne consume (soup) as a a thin sweet sugary raspberry sauce with some giant pieces of mint floating. The pieces of mint were unpleasant and bitter and she didnt taste any champagne at all. (I thought it did taste like alcohol). So overall, a bad dessert choice.
My dessert, on the other hand, was sooo good! GF took one bite and realized how wrong she'd been. Apparently the bread pudding being fresh and warm makes all the difference. She loved the butteryness and especially the vanilla frothy sauce so much that she ended up eating half of it.
I thought it was great too. It was very hot when I got it and I burned my tongue a bit when I got a spoonful of the inside. While GF liked the cream sauce, I liked the caramel sauce (because it was sweeter of course!). I dumped both on top as soon as I got it and then thought, "Huh, maybe I shouldn't have dumped it all on top--how is it going to seep down to the bottom?" Since I used most of the sauce GF had to shake the container of the cream sauce to try to get the last remnants. She even tried to stick a spoon in there but the spoon she had was too big to get in there.
It was definitely one of the best desserts of the week.
Overall it was an okay meal, but nothing was exceptional other than the bread pudding. And while that was really good, I wouldn't want to go back for an entire meal just for that. I think maybe Irish food just isn't my thing. Objectively the food was really good, but it just didn't excite me.