Deb -- I'm not sure what I would do -- I think I would lean towards following your strategy. That is such a hard age, and I do think they can be traumatized by things like that. We, too, always have our boys finish what they started, but I think this falls in to a different category. It's school, and not something he started on his own. I mean really, the Can-Can for boys? No wonder he doesn't want to do it.
PD and prayers to your son -- I hope a teacher can help make it more fun for the boys so that they don't mind their time in dance!
I can sympathize, as we are going through something too. My oldest son Andrew, who is 10, has been having problems in school with Brett -- someone who used to be a good friend. Brett started giving Andrew's best friend Kelton, a really hard time every day -- being mean, saying hurtful things etc. Kelton has MD, and has recently gotten a motorized wheelchair. I think Brett's problem is that Kelton is getting a lot of attention, plus everyone loves Kelton and Brett is jealous. I know it sounds crazy, because Kelton has such a lot of obstacles to overcome eacy day, but I do think that is part of the problem. Well, Andrew started taking up for Kelton, and now is one of Brett's targets. I've had all the usual discussions with Andrew -- tell Brett it's not nice, you're hurting people's feelings etc. but it has been getting worse, so I e-mailed his teacher last night. I'm hoping she can pay more attention to what is going on there (there are only 10 kids in the class) and try to get Brett to stop being so mean.