DD and I were on a mission since January to do all (or close to it) of the character meals this year. I go for the experience and character interaction and pics...I am sure we don't get our $$$ out of the food in many cases - especially the buffets. There are none that I strongly disliked, but some that I would never do again.
We have done 11 character meals, at 8 locations between 1/22/2006 & 6/30/2006. With the exception of three meals (Akerhaus, Chef Mickey & 1 time at Ohanas - the meals were just DD and I. We have DDE, which was great to save some $$$$$).
I would do 1900 Park Fare for B-fast again in a heart beat. Still need to do Chef Mickey for dinner & the one at The Land in EPCOT. Also want to try the one at Gullivers Grill/Swan with Timon and Rafiki.
****************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
Akerhaus/EPCOT/Princess Storybook Breakfast
Which Meal: Breakfast (Jan 22, 2006)
Which characters were present: Belle in lobby, Snow White, Mary Poppins, Jasmine, Princess Aurora
What foods were available: Family style - coffee, juice, eggs, potatoes, sausge & bacon & breads
What you ate: A little of everything - loved the potatoes
Positive Comments: It was our first character meal, enjoyed the company of our friends from NY! Characters were good with below exception
Negative Comments: This was our least favorite overall - Belle was grumpy - even they have a bad day!, very crowded, service was slow, juice was spilled, took 3 requests to get help cleaning it up, never go refills of drinks even when requested, crying little Tinkerbelle at the table behind us that in my opinion should have been removed from the table until she calmed down (she wanted out of her custom and nothing to do with the Princesess!! Mommy had other expectations though I guess!)
********************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
Donald's Breakfastosaurus/Animal Kingdom
Meal: Breakfast (Feb 5, 2006)
Which characters were present: Mickey, Donald, Pluto, Goofy
What foods were available: Buffet - very nice spread -
What you ate: Breakfast pizza, fruit, juice, eggs, don't recall what else - DD ate bacon
Positive Comments: This was fun - great characters. Food was good, server was great
Negative Comments: No real negatives - I had a bad morning getting there, so not the most relaxed breakfast... but not the fault of the restaurant.
*********************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
Cape May Cafe/Beach Club Resort
Which Meal: Breakfast
Which characters were present: Minnie, Goofy, Chip and Dale
What foods were available: buffet - mickey head waffles, eggs, bacon, etc
What you ate: waffles, eggs, bacon, fruit
Positive Comments: This was nice. We stayed at the BC for one night - (first time in a Disney resort!). It was quiet and relaxed. Characters were fun, our server was fabulous.
Negative Comments: None
********************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
O'Hana/Polynesian x2
Which Meal: breakfast (2/18/2006 - birthday breakfast & 6/4/2006 for a friend of DD's birthday party)
Which characters were present: Stitch, Mickey, Lilo & Pluto
What foods were available: assorted breads & fresh fruit, eggs, mickey head waffles, potato wedges & bacon/sausage.... and I got a choc chip birthday muffin
What you ate: a little of everything - PINEAPPLE bread to die for....
Positive Comments: Wonderful - I got a nice card signed by characters, a lei and the muffin with a candle for birthday. Characters were fun - Stitch and I hula'd. Server great.
6/3 meal awesome corner window table......
Negative Comments: none come to mind!!!
****************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
Crystal Palace in Magic Kingdom
Which Meal: dinner (2/22/2006 - my birthday dinner - spur of the moment - called in the morning.... had not planned on doing Disney on my mid-week b-day since DD had school)
Which characters were present: Pooh, Tigger, Piglet, Eeyore
What foods were available: You name it - spectacular buffet
What you ate: I honestly can't remember exactly what I ate - but I enjoyed the meal - DD was happy with her food as well.
Positive Comments: Another fabulous meal - table has streamers and mickey head confetti, nice b-day card and birthday cupcake. Very good server.
Negative Comments: None.
*********************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
1900 Park Fare - Grand Floridian
Which Meal: breakfast (late breakfast 11:15 ADR) (3/5/2006 - DD's 9th birthday - her friend and parents joined us as guests)
Which characters were present: Mary Poppins in lobby, Alice, Mad Hatter, Eeyore & Pooh
What foods were available: fabulous buffet - omelet station - a bit of everything!!
What you ate: strawberry soup - (yum), eggs, grits, bacon.... not sure what else! special birthday cake ordered from GF bakery
Positive Comments: LOVED IT - OUR ALL TIME FAVORITE - nice birthday place mat for b-day girl and Happy Birthday tiaras for both b-day girl and her friend - characters visited often and interacted wonderfully - playing with all the goodies I had given the girls in their "goodie bags". Mad Hatter sang Happy Birthday, Eeyore tried to steal the cake.... and so much more.
The choc/choc/choc cake was to DIE for. Glad I was local and they held it it the fridge for me while we went to MK!
Negative Comments: None!
*******************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
1900 Park Fare/Grand Floridian
Which Meal: Cinderellas Dinner (3/25/2006)
Which characters were present: Fairy Godmother in lobby, Cindy, Prince Charming, Suzie and Perla
What foods were available: Another spectacular buffet - some more strawberry soup, prime rib (i think that was the meat), pasta station, etc.
What you ate: Don't remember, but is was delish
Positive Comments: Very nice experience, characters were fun!
Negative Comments: None the fault of the restaurant... I again got the ADR on the spur of the moment and it was a bit too late for DD after being in school all day - so se was not too into the meal!
***********************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
Chef Mickey - Contemporary
Which Meal: Breakfast (4/9/2006 - joined by visiting Dsis and 6 yr old great nephew - this was his b-day breakfast)
Which characters were present: Minnie (did not come to table), Mickey, Chip & Dale, Goofy, Pluto & Mickey
What foods were available: Great buffet - mickey head waffles, fruit, breakfast pizza, eggs, and much much more
What you ate: breakfast pizza, fruit, eggs - grits maybe??? a breakfast lasagna type thing I think..... too busy having fun to eat!
Positive Comments: This was great - Dsis and Great nephew had never been to a character meal. I love watching the monorail.
Negative Comments: Too many families not following the "wait at your table" rule... several interuppted the interaction at our table..... never had this happen so much in one meal before.... CMs finally stepped in. (I tolerate a lot but don't get between me and my character pics!!!)
**********************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
Cinderella's Royal Table/Magic Kingdom
Which Meal: breakfast
Which characters were present: Cindy in lobby, Snow White, Princess Aurora, Belle, Fairy Godmother
What foods were available: fresh fruit & breads - Pre-plated - eggs, potatoes, bacon for kids; adults choice of stuffed french toast or yogurt.
What you ate

D had french toast sticks (she was not crazy about them) eggs, bacon (lots of bacon -she asked for seconds) and potatoes. I had stuffed french toast. sausage & potatoes.
Positive Comments: This was fun.... eating in castle was a special treat. Loved the view of Fantasyland and the tables were set very nice.
Negative Comments: None... it's something to experience once.
*******************************************************
Restaurant Name/Location:
Crystal Palace in Magic Kingdom
Which Meal: breakfast 6/30/2006 - spur of the momet 7am call for ADR)
Which characters were present: Pooh, Tigger, Piglet, Eeyore
What foods were available: You name it - spectacular buffet
What you ate: Fresh fruit, eggs, breakfast pizza, not sure what else... having too much fun to eat! DD loves the food here too.
Positive Comments: Another nice meal. Took day off from work to spend with DD.
Negative Comments: None