I'll vote again for the extra toys for the room. I had packed a lot of coloring, videos and small games. Next time I'll just bring one DVD and the animals they sleep with.
Also way over ordered from Garden Grocer*. Now I know. Only breakfast items and snacks to carry in the parks. The last thing we wanted at the room was junk food. Also, you can't overestimate how much bottled water you'll use. Even in Jan we went through a case.
Blister treatments. I brought 3-4 different treatments for blisters or aids to avoid blisters (mole skin etc...) Luckily it wasn't necessary. By the end I was almost hoping for DH to get a blister so I could feel proud that I was prepared.
I also didn't use the "nice" clothes I packed for myself or the make-up and hair stuff. (If you know you're planning a fancy night out, bring it, if not save the space.)
I'll still bring the hats. Maybe we'll wear them next year.

I know we should.
Things I didn't pack enough of:
Sweatpants. (To bring with us to pull on over our shorts when we were out and it cooled off. (Jan))
Flip-flops (we had to wear our sneakers to the pool)
Scissors. (Totally forgot these. Have you tried opening some of those toy packages with a nail clipper and a wine opener?)
Bandaids. (We ran out. They're small, no reason not to load up.)
*If you're looking for free fruit, walk through the villa area of a resort around check-out. 2 times we had other DVC guests offering us all the food they had left AND we did the same when we were checking out.**
** Note: We never took any. I'm sure if was fine, but the whole "never take food from strangers" precluded me from accepting unknown banannas. That and the entire bunch sitting on our counter.
