OK, I may repeat some of what Tozzie says, but I just wanted to start out by saying I agree with everything she said!
Good:
First and foremost are the Adventure Guides. They really, REALLY know what it takes to make a trip seamless and effortless (for us) and special and just plain enjoyable. When I think about the
ABD's I've taken (3 so far!) besides the wonderful places I've seen, one of the first things I think about is how fabulous the Guides were. I agree that having 2 of them is a serious plus. During hikes one can lead, the other can follow up behind with the slow folks. One can go inside with folks, and the other can stay outside for a bit taking folks' pictures. Plus, the interaction between the 2 Guides just adds to the atmosphere, because they are friendly & happy & joke with each other, etc. The one trip where the Guides didn't quite have the best interaction, I really missed it.
The Guides will also go above & beyond some times, helping to arrange extra activities or dinner reservations. I have some serious dietary issues (diabetic, reflux) and the Guides are FABULOUS about making sure that there is food that fits my diet. I can't do tomatoes or barbeque sauce. On SWS, one meal was, basically, a barbeque, and all the meats were slathered in barbeque sauce. Our guide went & talked to the servers, and out came a platter of all of the meats with no sauce on them. My doctor has me eating a cup of plain yogurt a day. In Alaska, the Guides bought yogurt & kept it refrigerated for me, so I had it every day. On SWS, they made sure each hotel had the yogurt for me at breakfast. Red Cliffs Lodge did not until the last day, and the Guides felt so bad about it, they bought me a bottle of wine as an apology! I knew it wasn't their fault, but they felt responsible. It's nice to have someone looking out for you (ESPECIALLY because I travel solo). I was amazed at how the Guides in the Med managed to get me food at every port that didn't have tomatoes in it (no mean trick in the Med!).
Not having to worry (or in some cases, even think much). I'm with Tozzie. I have to think & plan & worry at work every day, and it is just so relaxing NOT HAVING TO while on vacation. The logistics are all taken care of for you. The biggest decision is "where am I going to eat during our free time?" And the Guides can help you with that, too! Transportation is all taken care of. Show up when you're supposed to, and you will be taken where you need to go. Get there, and a local guide is waiting there for you. Don't worry about tickets to get into places, any sort of admission, tips for local guides, etc, etc. Oh, and it's MAGIC!, but your luggage shows up at your hotel without you having to shlep it!
VIP Access. Not having to wait & stand in line is a tremendous bonus. Plus, ABD gets you into places & doing things that you just couldn't arrange on your own. Meals on small farms. The Alaska SeaLife museum after hours for a pizza party. Early entrance onto the boat for our Kenai penninsula tour, so that we got choice seats. The Disney name does carry weight.
All the little touches. I love the boxes ABD sends out 45 days before your trip. I know it's silly, but I adore the little countdown calendar they send out. I tack it up in my cubicle at work, and cross off each day of the last month leading up to my trip. It really helps with the excitement. The Theme that each day has. It's really a great way to start up the discussion of where we're headed for the day. And the daily pins that match the theme. What a great touch! The ABD logo stuff they give you (I still wish they did T-shirts!)
OK, this may not be a big deal for everyone, but I love that
the Guides already know where all the bathrooms are throughout the day, and make sure you get a chance to use them. It's built into the travel time. This was especially important in the Med. I've wasted a lot of time on vacation hunting down bathrooms. It's one less thing to worry about.
The activities. I really love the mix of things that ABD has set up for you to do. There's a lot of walking around/sightseeing, time to look around museums, active things, restful things, just a really nice mix. I can't think of a single activity on an ABD that I didn't like. And they are flexible enough to find alternatives if there is something you don't want (or can't) participate in.
The Bad:
Gotta agree with Tozzie again.
The food. The meals seem aimed at the lowest common denominator. More on the bland side. A bit generic rather than truly the food of the region. If I'm traveling somewhere, I'd rather have local food than stuff that looks like what I eat back in Ohio. I realize they have to cater to a lot of folks from a lot of places (and probably some picky kids), but I wish there was an option to get something more authentic. I think a few of the trips do this (like Peru and the Med cruise add-on) but I think most do not.
And the lack of a loyalty program kind of bites. They really seem to not care if people come back or not, as far as their booking & pricing seems concerned. I'm going on my 4th ABD, and as far as booking goes, there's no difference between me and a first-timer. You get an extra pin, but that's about it.
There's really very little advantage to booking early. As Tozzie said, a lot of the incentives & special offers come out months after the trips are announced, and if you've already booked, you're out of luck. With the non-refundable deposit, you're kind of stuck if better pricing or great incentives come out.
Some people would say that the price is a Bad, but I believe you get what you pay for. Yes, of course it would be nice to get an ABD for less, but I believe that they are worth the price. You really get that extra service, inventive itineraries and just Disney quality that you wouldn't get with a cheaper company. I'm willing to pay a bit more to get a seamless, engaging trip. And while I can, I will.
If I think of more, I'll be back!
Sayhello