That bolded part is probably soooo true, well, for an adult. I think a skittish kid would still appreciate that over the random screaming.
I'm trying to remember if I was THAT obnoxious during my preteen and teen years going to Great American a million times. I know that even in college (and now) my friends and I can talk a million miles an hour, and I'm sure there was much giggling. But screaming for no reason? I just don't know.
It was my kiddo that spurred that discussion, b/c he was just fine until everyone shrieked in the overlayed HM. He could not be calmed down, and we ended up taking the chicken exit. By the way, that's not recommended by me...now that I've seen the overlay version I don't know that I agree, but at the time I had the strong feeling that we would have been less scared by just going on the ride, rather than walk those halls. Maybe it's changed since October of '06, but back then the walls were painted black, there were very few signs, and the halls just went on and on. By the time we got out (it lets you out back by the holiday-time FP machines) we were BOTH in tears.
I wonder if the CMs would let a parent and skittish kid in to the accessible entrance where you don't take the stretching room? Is there such a think at
Disneyland? I thought I read there was. Seems a little naughty, and they might think "if the kid is that scared of screams he shouldn't go on", but I dunno, my kid was fine until the shrieking started...seems it was the screams that got to him.
All that said, once I saw the HMH version, I was glad E hadn't gone on it. Especially b/c I was freaked out by it, and would have had a hard time containing my "bleah I hate this" reaction.
People scream on Pirates?????? That's just sad.