bcla
On our rugged Eastern foothills.....
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2012
- Messages
- 25,873
It's not as much the money as it is being hesitant to pay for a hotel that gets worse reviews than the one we can stay at for free. Mostly, it appears Maswik Lodge isn't in a great location as far as the in park hotels go.
It appears we could get one night at Thunderbird Lodge. What did you think about it? Was it walkable to any other hotels for more food options? That's one thing we loved about Yellowstone. Also, did they have an elevator? I tried a Google search, but nothing came up. I can't climb steps, so I can't take a chance on being assigned a second floor room without an elevator. If you don't remember, we'll try calling later.
ETA: After I booked two nights, I saw they don't have an elevator. That may be a problem.We'll have to call to see if they can guarantee ground floor.
The thing about national parks is that there are a lot of basic accomodations that are are there on the premise that the public should be able to afford it. Like I said - I stayed at the Maswik quad cabins years ago, although those are gone. The location wasn't that close to the rim, but it wasn't bad really.
As far as Thuinderbird Lodge goes, it's somewhat controversial. It looks OK, but it was built in a similar style as the Mission 66 program to build lots of newer buildings for the National Park Service by 1966. And lots of them were built in a more contemporary style than what had been "National Park rustic" for years. The criticism would be that it kind of looks out of place - like a commercial motel was dropped into a national park.
We'll have to call to see if they can guarantee ground floor.


Try the hottest day on record, 6/26/90 clocking in at 126. I remember it vividly because it was the day after I got my drivers license and I went to the movies with my friends only to come out to a puddle of radiator fluid leaking due to the excessive heat. Even my car said this heat is too much.
Unfortunately, when I clicked to see what was available, it was a room with no view & no elevator access. After seeing the no elevator note, DH decided to call Thunderbird Lodge to request a ground floor room for the reservation we already have booked.

My sisterinlaw lives in Phoenix and we visit once a year. After looking at sand, no grass or trees (the type I'm used to), just desert landscaping, I was really missing Mn. It's very nice to visit with a lot to see and do, but I don't think I could live there. However, we live in the very cold north. The only reason we stay here is because of the kids and grandkids