Survivor All Star OFFICIAL THREAD!

[faithinkarma]

I don't feel sorry for Mogo Mogo losing all the challenges at all. They (Lex) made it their strategy to oust the strongest players first. Losing challennges is a direct consequence of that decision.

 

[IloveDMB]

When is Mogo Mogo going to realize that their strategy is not working? Why would they let go of Ethan now, and not later when they are all one big tribe? Me thinks that their strategy is dumb!

 

[Rippington'sFan]

I think it was the right move. I was surprised that Ethan was voted out unanimously. I thought Jerri was a gone after her brain cramp during the bow and arrow thing.
They don't know exactly when the merge will happen so I think it was in their best interest to get rid of Ethan because he was their biggest threat. Jerri is no threat to anybody so why not keep her around longer knowing she won't get much further. I agree with their strategy.

Hey, I'm from metro-Boston and I must say I cannot stand Boston Rob. What a arrogant,cocky A**H*LE. He gives Boston a bad name. I hope he goes next.

 

[Rajah]

Well, I disagree -- I'm really enjoying this season, and getting to see different angles on old favorites (and least favorites).

The last time Rob was on the show, I hated him. This season, though, I'm kinda liking him for a player. He is NOT someone I would want to have as a "friend" or know in person, but he does make for some interesting TV.

I was also sad to see Ethan go. Made some pretty good sense from an individual standpoint, but c'mon, the merge hasn't happened yet!

It'll be interesting to see what happens next week.

 

[always quiet]

I just watched the preview for next week's show on cbs.com. What I find odd is that on the clips from last night, it showed what appeared to be the making of 2 new tribes (mixing everyone up). That wasn't shown at all on the website clip. Looks to be a lot of un-challenge related happenings.

 

[gometros]

Originally posted by Tulirose
Hi TiggerPiglet - I'm bummed too because this would have been a great way to advance. You can only hope gometros and bzelf did not get in under the deadline too.

Sorry, Rose, but after goofing once last during Pearl Islands, I don't leave anything to chance. Obviouslt bzelf got in too (unfortunately

WIther way, we;re blowing the other groups away. We've got twice as many points as the second place group.

 

[Kirby]

It would have been great if they all turned on Lex. Wouldn't that have been a surprise!

I saw Ethan on the Early Show. He was really mad at Lex at first, but things are cool now. He said that he thought Lex was talking out of both sides of his mouth, saying that it was all business but he was coming to him as a friend.

Ethan was asked if he enjoyed this time around. He said no, because you know what to expect, that he would be cold, hungry and tired all the time. Looking back he said he may have enjoyed a little, like the challenges but for the most part he was miserable.

He was asked if he thought that he might have fared better on a team with Tom since he, Tom and Lex were all good friends in Africa. He said that he and Tom discussed that not too long ago and Tom felt that it wouldn't have been good for him since they were good friends. A comment was made to Ethan about Tom being smarter than he looked and Ethan agreed.

Ethan was asked about Boston Rob and Amber's relationship on the show. He responded that if someone could find romance on the show, more power to them (or something like that).

That's all that I can really remember at the moment. He would have liked to stay in longer but at least he is able to say that he stayed in longer than any of the other "winners".

 

[JulianneP]

I just watched the preview of next week show on CBS.com and it looks like they are going to recap highlights of previous shows. Not what they showed on last night show. It is also going to be on Wednesday night again. So I wondering if they are doing a recap on WEdnesday and the a new show on Thrusday or is the stupid basketball tornament going to mess everything up again. Which means then we will have to wait 2 weeks for a new show!!! Oh how I hate March Madness. (Don't tell my Terp DH though)

 

[always quiet]

I have the new tv guide and yes, basketball is messing everything up!! No Survivor on Thursday!!

 

[MickeyBabe]

DIS All Stars score for last week (3-17-04) was 8824


Sorry I forgot to post it. I was so bummed about not getting my newsletter points in on time. I got it right this week!

 

[Jeafl]

I thought last night was rather boring. I did chuckle at Colby's "chapped hide" though. I don't recall them ever mentioning Chapera's matching necklaces before, nor did I even notice them all wearing them before.

I just realized while watching last night that I don't really care who wins as long as it isn't Boston Rob. All of my favorites are now voted off, with the possible exception of Rupert. And even him I don't like this season as much as last season. This whole season has been kind of a let down, and fairly boring. I was expecting a lot more from the "All-Stars".

 

[DISshopkeeper]

This whole season has been kind of a let down, and fairly boring. I was expecting a lot more from the "All-Stars".

I agree, Jill. I'm beginning to think that the character development that we get with the unknowns is a big part of the enjoyment for me.

And last night's episode was BORING BORING BORING.

Though I am finding Amber more likeable and charming every week.

 

[faithinkarma]

I just realized while watching last night that I don't really care who wins as long as it isn't Boston Rob. All of my favorites are now voted off, with the possible exception of Rupert. And even him I don't like this season as much as last season. This whole season has been kind of a let down, and fairly boring.

You took the words right out of my mouth. I had the excact same feeling last night. I simply don't care all that much who wins. I still have an attachment to Rupert, but he is not as interesting as he was last time.

I don't really want to see Lex win because I think he was foolish getting rid of challenge winners too early. On the other hand, it may have been a gutsy move, so I won't mourn if he does win.

Boston Rob is certainly being presented as the a** of the world. So basically the only real emotion I can muster for this series is the hope of seeing Rob get his comeuppance.

 

[Alice28]

I thought parts of last night's episode were hilarious----DH and I were Laughing our you know what's off at Rob C's impression of Jeff (I had seen it on CBS.com's extras but it was still hilarious) and at the Rob trying to decipher Big Tom. Too funny!

I don't know, I"m still quite attached to some of these players. I am really rooting for a Big Tom, Lex and Kathy final 3. I hope Jerri is the next to get the boot and then Rob.

 

[CPM]

I thought some parts were pretty funny, Colby's chapped whatever and them imitating the other tribe was a hoot! Rob C. imitated Jeff to a tee!
I guess I'm in the minority but I like Boston Rob, I find him very amusing. Keeps the show entertaining.

 

[shortbun]

I'm softening on Boston Rob. He really seems to be attached
to Amber and not just for the extra vote. His first go round with
the woman he attached to was awful, this time he seems vulnerable and I like that side of him. The replays of Big Tom's
southern speak were really funny! I'm glad this review was more
humor, the others have focused on extra drama. I'm rooting for
Amber to win, she'll have to throw over Boston Rob but hey,
better to share a million that not have won at all.

 

[mickeyboat]

I am a Rob M fan. He seems to really remember why they are all there. It's all in the editing!

"Best case scenario - we (Amber and I) will share my million dollars, worst case, we'll share hers."

Denae

 

[DemonLlama]

gometros --

I'm kinda confused on the point situation.

DIS Survivor has 10144.

Even taking the TOP eight scores (published on the public team board) they would only have 13749.

How is your tribe's score double the second place one?

 

[gometros]

We're that good

 

[palmtreegirl]

Originally posted by CPM
I thought some parts were pretty funny, Colby's chapped whatever and them imitating the other tribe was a hoot! Rob C. imitated Jeff to a tee!
I guess I'm in the minority but I like Boston Rob, I find him very amusing. Keeps the show entertaining.

I hated Boston Rob the first time he was on Survivor but I really like him this time. He works gard and is playing the game well. It's funny because some players I loved the first time, I don't like and vice-versa.

Use to like-

Rupert- I loved him last time but this time I'm not thrilled with him at all. The way he treated Jenna when she was leaving really bothered me, he takes the *game* way too seriously and the guy needs to learn to relax and laugh at himself a bit. I think he's insecure this time around and I like confident Rupert much, much better. Too bad, I use to really like him.

Kathy- I loved her last time this time-ICK! She's such a brat.

Shi Ann- UGH, she's so annoying thime around, I want her and Kathy gone.

Hated now like-

Jerri- ACK! I'm actually finding myself rooting for her this time! lol. I think she has made some valid points, like Rupert not listening and building that stupid shelter. I like her this time-shocking!

Boston Rob- I really like him, he's funny, can laugh at himself, works hard and is playing a good game.

Amber- Did this girl even speak last time? lol. This time she seems like a really nice girl, she was so sweet to Jenna, I'm rooting for her to go far.

Lex- wasn't a big fan last time but I like him this time.

Overall- I think the first part of tyhis season was a little boring but next week looks like it's going to really shake things up, can't wait!