You're all pulling at my heartstrings with this! We went to Storyland every year, at least once, for 13 years until my kids decided they were too old.
We just LOVE it up there! We liked eating at the Muddy Moose, the 99's (yes, I know those are everywhere, but it became a tradition), Up Country always looked good, but also always had a line! Many of the local places are very good as well....Bellini's in the Outlet Mall is good, though you're better off taking the food out as it's really small.
Have a great time! Think of me when you're riding the Wooden Shoes, those were my favorite!