I have been to EVERY Catherines store in Orlando and up and down our route driving from New Brunswick.
I LOVE Catherines and I find it to be like a Pennington's with a bit of AdditionElle's higher quality stuff.
I love their Jean Capri's and the cotton blouses are really nice. I bought 12 knit tops while there that I am going to use as my uniform at work (we own our own summer business) I bought every colour and love them. (They keep their shape well)
Lane Bryant is very nice, professional with some more casual stuff as well (think Additionelle) and AVENUE has nice clothes but the worst sales people in the world and it's hard to find the sizes. Imagine having to find the tag on the inside of each pair of jeans while they are hanging just to find out which size they are. Very frustrating. We were in one in Orlando and it was 45 minutes without a hello. It was obvious I was looking for sizes and even when DH asked if someone was available to help me, they were no help. There were 2 people working and in that time, there was only one other person who came in and one was checking out when I arrived.
I liked some of their clothes but after all that, I could not deal with that kind of frustration ever again.
I hope this helped.
I got so many clothes at Catherines that I do not have to buy any for the coming summer. On this trip alone, I got 5 blouses, 1 winter jacket, 1 fall jacket, 12 knit shirts with collars that look like they have a t-shirt under them (6 solid and 6 stripes), 6 jean capris and I was pleased with it all.
Now, I did not get this all at one store but there are a few in Orlando and I made a point of going to each one because DH is so nice about me buying things I like to wear. They have great clearance sections as well.
Let me know if this helps. Also, I am not a size 14...I am truly plus size(LOL) and I wanted nice, comfortable, quality clothes and I am not into dressing up too much as our business is casual. (We own a motel and chalet business so I only work summers and there is no dress code because I am the boss...LOL)