Stop Picking On Lindsay Lohan

DawnCt1

<font color=red>I had to wonder what "holiday" he
Joined
May 17, 2004
Messages
30,053
Every now and then there is an op ed piece in the WSJ suitable for posting here on the Dis. (apolitical ;) ) I think that this is a good one. What does she have in common with Britney Spears? She was a meal ticket for her greedy parents, unlike Dakota Fanning, etc who seemed to have been protected and nurtured by their parents. That said, while many express concern and hope for her future, I do hear a lot of negativity with regard to her "entitlement". I think this piece puts it into some perspective.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703724104575379232973072858.html
Stop Picking On Lindsay Lohan
Why do some people rejoice in the unraveling of a life and career?
Article

By REBECCA MACATEE

Both of my legs are covered in ghastly, purple bruises. I'm not a soccer player, and I don't have an abusive boyfriend. You might say I'm a party girl.

My bruises come from clumsily crashing onto a concrete New York City sidewalk. I'd been out with some girlfriends, was wearing too-tall stilettos and a few glasses of champagne had disturbed my sense of balance.

After taking that tumble, I laughed a little too loudly, reassured some good Samaritans that I was okay, hopped right back up and continued on with my night. It was a fun evening with my girls—there was no alcohol poisoning, no random hookups, no brushes with the law. I made it home safely and into work on time the next morning.

Aside from a friend's Twitter posting about my fall, there was no evidence of the trouble I'd been up to the night before. There were no viral videos of me hitting the pavement, no photographs of me flipping off aggressive paparazzi, and no hearsay reports of how "wasted" I had been at the club.

But I'm not Lindsay Lohan, the actress who yesterday began a 90-day jail sentence for violating the terms of her probation, set in 2007 after she pleaded no contest to charges of drunk driving and being under the influence of cocaine.

I didn't star in a feature film when I was 11 years old, or support my family financially before I'd even hit puberty. I don't have a father who talks publicly about my intimate struggles in order to make a few bucks. Paparazzi don't stalk me 24 hours a day to capture my every mistake. And tabloids don't dominate newsstands by exaggerating my wild partying. In other words, there's not a cruel cultural obsession with rejoicing in the apparent unraveling of my life and career.

Of course, my behaviors are not nearly as extreme as Ms. Lohan's. I've never been a part of a car chase or a drug bust nor, thankfully, have I struggled with anorexia or substance addiction. But, like any 24-year-old girl, I make mistakes and have my regrets. It's just that the world isn't watching me every step of the way.

Most people can't begin to relate to Ms. Lohan's experiences of childhood stardom, of being lauded as impossibly talented and beautiful while being thrust into a world of unlimited privilege. Obstacles that deter most of us in our formative years didn't exist for her. Money was not an issue, drugs and alcohol were readily available, parental supervision was minimal, and hired professionals apparently couldn't tell her "no."

I like to think that if I had been a celebrity at a young age, I would have been like Natalie Portman or Dakota Fanning, starlets who stayed grounded and career-focused despite their surreal careers. But I can imagine how easily one can give into the dangerous temptations that Ms. Lohan did.

Drunk driving is deplorable. Blowing off court-ordered responsibilities and showing up to trial with expletives scrawled on your fingernails is not the way to garner respect. And Ms. Lohan is not above the law.

But eating disorders, alcoholism, drug addiction and apparent psychological illness should not be laughed at by the American public. Since I can't guarantee that I wouldn't have succumbed to similar demons had I lived a life like Ms. Lohan's, I won't gawk at her condition, and I will root for her to get the help she desperately needs.

She's a talented actress and, admit it, we all hope for a Lohan cameo in the upcoming "Mean Girls" sequel.

Ms. Macatee is a writer in New York.
 
I totally agree. We are a society that is all to quick to throw stones.
 
Good article. I feel so bad for that poor girl. It just isn't right to treat people like they are entertainment, I don't know how she can stand it. I'm rooting for Lindsay too and hoping she can make a come-back like Robert Downey Jr.
 
this is why I disagree with all the people on here that were so happy, she is doing time! She needs help, NOT to be in jail! but I guess that is not going to work for all you people who where so happy! because she will be out in around 2 weeks......so how does that help? It does not!
 

this is why I disagree with all the people on here that were so happy, she is doing time! She needs help, NOT to be in jail! but I guess that is not going to work for all you people who where so happy! because she will be out in around 2 weeks......so how does that help? It does not!

It helps because it shows her that their are consequences for her actions. For her total disregard of the law and the judges orders. Painting F you on her fingernail at her sentencing was nothing more then a slap in the face to that judge. She says it was a joke, and if people believe that then they are pretty gullible. Can you imagine having the stupidly and audacity to do something like that? She is lucky the judge did not see it and throw her in jail right then and there for contempt.

I feel bad for her. I really do. Her parents did not parent her. They indulged and used her and their is no excuse for that. They have helped create who she is now. She has had the responsibility of supporting her parents and her siblings since she was very young. I can't imagine the pressure that create in her.

Often times in Hollywood you will end up with people who are over indulged. They are surrounded by yes man who will do whatever is asked of them. They are told time and time again how wonderful they are. When that happens you end up with people who feel that the rules don't apply to them and that everyone will do things their way, even the police and the judges.

Sometimes they need a big wake up call like this to wake them up to reality. It seemed to work for Paris Hilton and it certainly worked for Robert Downey JR and I'm sure it probably worked for many others. I am hoping that it works for Lindsey and that she will seek the help that she needs to get her life back on track.
 
Feel bad for her all you want but nobody forced her to act the ways she chose to act. She does need help but she also needs to pay the price for her actions.
 
this is why I disagree with all the people on here that were so happy, she is doing time! She needs help, NOT to be in jail! but I guess that is not going to work for all you people who where so happy! because she will be out in around 2 weeks......so how does that help? It does not!

Sometimes jail translates to help. She has been in rehab before. She has been in outpatient treatment before. I don't rejoice in her going to jail. I get no pleasure out of it, but it may be part of the bigger picture for her recovery.
 
I try to ignore all the celebrity gossip stuff but this has been popping up everywhere. It appears to me that she has had ample opportunity to show the judge she was making an effort to meet the terms of her parole and she has not complied. If she were my child, I'd want her to get a wake up call that actions have consequences. It's hard to feel sorry for someone who has been behaving like an entitled brat. I do think she needs help and hopefully this will give her the nudge she needs to do that because nothing else has seemed to work.
 
Feel bad for her all you want but nobody forced her to act the ways she chose to act. She does need help but she also needs to pay the price for her actions.

Exactly. It isn't like this is her first time getting in trouble. She's been down this road before. I felt bad for her the first time, and maybe the second time.. but at this point, it's all her. With her money, she has all the resources in the world to get help (and has tried several times in the past), and she's still getting in trouble. I feel like at this point, she doesn't WANT help.
 
With everything going on in this country I've been shocked that this has received the news time that it has. Frankly, I don't give a rat's behind about this.
 
It helps because it shows her that their are consequences for her actions. For her total disregard of the law and the judges orders. Painting F you on her fingernail at her sentencing was nothing more then a slap in the face to that judge. She says it was a joke, and if people believe that then they are pretty gullible. Can you imagine having the stupidly and audacity to do something like that? She is lucky the judge did not see it and throw her in jail right then and there for contempt.

I feel bad for her. I really do. Her parents did not parent her. They indulged and used her and their is no excuse for that. They have helped create who she is now. She has had the responsibility of supporting her parents and her siblings since she was very young. I can't imagine the pressure that create in her.

Often times in Hollywood you will end up with people who are over indulged. They are surrounded by yes man who will do whatever is asked of them. They are told time and time again how wonderful they are. When that happens you end up with people who feel that the rules don't apply to them and that everyone will do things their way, even the police and the judges.

Sometimes they need a big wake up call like this to wake them up to reality. It seemed to work for Paris Hilton and it certainly worked for Robert Downey JR and I'm sure it probably worked for many others. I am hoping that it works for Lindsey and that she will seek the help that she needs to get her life back on track.

I am not sure that her parents even bothered to indulge her. I think they took her money and hired other people to indulge her, which is even sadder. She needs to learn the lessons that she didn't or couldn't as a child growing up; behavior has consequences. Its time.
 
With everything going on in this country I've been shocked that this has received the news time that it has. Frankly, I don't give a rat's behind about this.

Yes, but the Dis rules prevent us from talking about everything else going on in the country. ;)
 
Hey, I am not one to run out casting stones...
But, looking at her behaviors (no matter the excuses) yes, I will make my judgements. And, I make no apology for that...

I have to disagree with this article.

Yes, just sometimes, one is held accountable for inexcusable behaviors.

Allowing the 'excuses' and 'pity' offered up here will not help this girl....

As for those who say that she obviously needs 'help', not jail time.... Most people in the know realize that Lohan is not, and probably never will be, in the position to get help or to help herself. (totally out of control, oblivious to any boundaries) I have heard it said that incarceration might actually be the best thing for her, and be her savior, because it could possibly force her into the help and the change of events that she needs.
 
Exactly. It isn't like this is her first time getting in trouble. She's been down this road before. I felt bad for her the first time, and maybe the second time.. but at this point, it's all her. With her money, she has all the resources in the world to get help (and has tried several times in the past), and she's still getting in trouble. I feel like at this point, she doesn't WANT help.

I think part of the reason she doesn't want help is because she feels that she is doing nothing wrong. Whether it is because she thinks that she is above the law or because she is in denial, who knows. :confused3
 
I am not sure that her parents even bothered to indulge her. I think they took her money and hired other people to indulge her, which is even sadder. She needs to learn the lessons that she didn't or couldn't as a child growing up; behavior has consequences. Its time.

Yup, they probably did. Her parents just make me sick. They are a lesson in how not to parent. Her mother was more interested in being her friend and going clubbing with her. :sad2: Just do everything the opposite of them and the kids should come out okay. ;)
 
Yup, they probably did. Her parents just make me sick. They are a lesson in how not to parent. Her mother was more interested in being her friend and going clubbing with her. :sad2: Just do everything the opposite of them and the kids should come out okay. ;)

I agree. "Mom" should write a parenting book called, "This is what I did, do the opposite".
 
Didn't Brittney's mother already write this book? ;)

Yes and Kate Gosselin wrote the sequel ;)


ANYWAYS, Lilo is in jail NOT because of having problems and going there instead of rehab, but because she broke the law.

Afterwards she is going to rehab. Once she gets out, I don't think she will be any different.
 
Yes and Kate Gosselin wrote the sequel ;)


ANYWAYS, Lilo is in jail NOT because of having problems and going there instead of rehab, but because she broke the law.

Afterwards she is going to rehab. Once she gets out, I don't think she will be any different.

No, no. Kate Gosslin wrote the "happy marriage" book. :rotfl:

OK, I get no pleasure from Lindsay's problems, but unfortunately I agree with you that she does not seem ready to change yet. Hopefully jail will actually wake her up and maker try in rehab.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom