Steak, which 2 of these would you choose?

[KyraS]

We are going to choose 2 of the following and looking for an excellent Steak Dinner, which should we choose?

1. Jiko
2. California Grill
3. Yachtsman Steak House
3. Citricos
4. Narcoossees
5. Flying Fish

Or make a recommendation, looking for signature dining from the dining plan, thank!

 

[lacrosse_lady72]

FOR STEAK?

Yachtsman Steakhouse and Jiko

If Artist Point brings the buffalo steak back, then I would replace Jiko with AP.

 

[crisi]

Shula's if you aren't on the dining plan, don't have kids, and want to drop cash.

If you are and want a steak selection, Yachtsman is your only choice. The others aren't steak houses, they have good steak, but its a single choice.

The macncheese steak at Jiko is good.

 

[HelenParr]

We would choose: Yachtsman and Flying Fish (stipulating that the Flying Fish Steak is pepper encrusted with a sauce -- not everyone's favorite, but we like it). Yachtsman will be more tradiotnal STEAK with more cuts from which to choose.

 

[madalex]

Jiko for the filet with mac and cheese and Yachtsman for the broader steak selection. That being said, the steak selections on the menu at CG and FF are also very good, but if you don't like what is offered, there is no alternative steak entree.

 

[D&R love Disney]

Shula's has the best steak but it's not on the dining plan. Out of your list I'd go for Jiko and Yachtsman Steakhouse.

 

[kmk1180]

We are going to choose 2 of the following and looking for an excellent Steak Dinner, which should we choose?

1. Jiko
2. California Grill
3. Yachtsman Steak House
3. Citricos
4. Narcoossees
5. Flying Fish

Or make a recommendation, looking for signature dining from the dining plan, thank!

Of this list...Jiko.
It's worth it. The steak is great and you'll be surpised how you like the mac and cheese. (different that any other mac and cheese you've had before)
Best adult resturant at Disney!
Service amazing. Most knowledgable servers I've ever had at Disney.
Wine selection is...wow good.
Flat breads are to die for.

 

[Paging Tom Morrow]

As a proud carnivore, I claim Narcoossee's as the best steak on property.

California Grill places 2nd.

 

[Ralph&Pam]

FOR STEAK?

Yachtsman Steakhouse and Jiko

If Artist Point brings the buffalo steak back, then I would replace Jiko with AP.

I must concur about Yachtsman Steakhouse and Jiko, although I cannot comment on the Artist Point replacement. I always have the salmon at AP.

 

[webray]

We are going to choose 2 of the following and looking for an excellent Steak Dinner, which should we choose?

1. Jiko The filet with mac and cheese is good, just missing a lot of the mac n cheese
2. California Grill never had steak here
3. Yachtsman Steak House disgusting and poor service
3. Citricos
4. Narcoossees
5. Flying Fish best steak on disney property..ask for sauce on the side

Or make a recommendation, looking for signature dining from the dining plan, thank!

.......................

 

[Aimeedyan]

I had the filet at Citricos, Yachtsman, and Jiko. Believe it or not, the cut served at Citricos that night was the best of the 3. That said, if you're looking for a steak - go to the steakhouse (Yachtsman). Those signature spots all offer a steak but not a steakhouse selection. Yachtsman also handcuts their steaks daily.

 

[Rebelmom67]

I will probably be flamed broiled for this, but.....

The last 2 times I was at YSH, I had subpar beef. I was disappointed the first time, but plain out mad the second time! I ordered the Chatuabriand for the first visit - flavourless and overcooked and the Waygu beef the next time. The Waygu beef was very gristly and such a disappointment.

I recommend the filet from Jiko and Le Cellier (even though that wasn't an option )

 

[teddygurl28]

i enjoyed Yachtsman Steakhouse very much, and plan to go back, for a disney "steakhouse" its good, not what i would concider a top steakhouse, but i along with my boyfriend enjoyed our meals very much, the others i could not tell you

 

[NJFireman22]

For myself Jiko, My DW loves Raglin Roads filet.
As for off property we both love Johnnys Hideaway, and Charlie's.

 

[Pakey]

If you are looking for variety, YSH is your best bet although I've had some less than stellar pieces of meat on a few of my visits there. Other times, have been very good.

If you want a good filet served in an unusual manner, then I'd pick Jiko's. However, I think the best items on Jiko's menu are the appetizers and soups.

 

[foulkfamilyof5]

We are going to choose 2 of the following and looking for an excellent Steak Dinner, which should we choose?

1. Jiko
2. California Grill
3. Yachtsman Steak House
3. Citricos
4. Narcoossees
5. Flying Fish

Or make a recommendation, looking for signature dining from the dining plan, thank!

LaCellier in Epcot hands down...the best steak I have ever had

 

[falling2infinity319]

California Grill makes a Filet Mignon to die for.

 

[MickeyNicki]

Jiko and Flying Fish

 

[Sugardimples]

I thought the filet I had at Yachtsman was the best I ever had.

 

[Hopefully]

My Choices would be Jiko and Narcoosee's.
Another family here that does not like the Yachtsman's Steakhouse. We have tried twice and our food was just not good. We will not go back again.