steak question - Le Cellier vs. Shula's

[ellenmiele]

DH is a carnivore, and we have eaten at Yachtsman steakhouse which we loved and for our upcoming trip I (finally) got an ADR for Le Cellier. But just this week, allearsnet had an outstanding review of Shula's . So the question is ...... Le Cellier or Shula's? (park entry not an issue - will have APs)

 

[tlrotzoll]

I just booked my Nov vacation & the reservations rep (her name is Mars) recommended Le Cellier. I hadn't even asked for recommendations & she just offered that, so I imagine it has to be good. I was not planning on going there, but I may wind up rearranging my plans so that I can.

 

[jadedbeauty14304]

Both.

LeCellier is more than just a good steak, it is an experience.

 

[tlrotzoll]

Both.

LeCellier is more than just a good steak, it is an experience.

How did you do your ticker? I am "computer stupid" & can't seem to figure it out!

 

[jadedbeauty14304]

How did you do your ticker? I am "computer stupid" & can't seem to figure it out!

Go to either Mickeypath dot com or tickerfactory dot com depending on the one you like, and follow the directions


Just to clarify, LeCellier is in Canada at Epcot, in a beautiful cellar dining room, your server is Canadian, and every one that we have ever had liked to talk a little about where they are from and what it is like there. There is an amazing cheddar Cheese soup appetizer, and the variety of breads that they start with is wonderful, (especially the pretzelbread, yum!). These things, (to me) make it more than just a good steak. It makes it an experience.

 

[Lockandbayb]

Just to let you know, we ate at Le cellier last year and i got the steak, It was great! we havent been to Shula's so i couldnt tell you which is better, But if you pick Le cellier you wont be dissapointed!

 

[disfanRN]

We loved Lecellier until they took our favorite filet off the menu recently.(maple barbecue)

 

[ElizabethB]

There is no comparison. Shula's steaks are miles beyond Le Cellier in quality. Le Cellier is similar to a Sizzler or Outback Steakhouse. Le Cellier is exceedingly dark, crowded and noisy. We ate there once and have not been back.

When we want a prime black angus steak that is the best steak on property (aside from the genuine Japanese wagyu beef that is sometimes available for a surcharge at V&A), we go to Shula's.

 

[kardut]

Shula's, without a doubt. Their steak is similar to Mortons and Ruth's Chris, and they have a wide variety of cuts to choose from. As previous poster said, Le Cellier is more along the lines of Outback...a nice experience, to be sure, but the steak is not top of the line.

 

[scrappinMickey]

Another vote for Shula's. We love eating at Morton's for the best steak and Shula's is similar to that.