This will be our 4th trip to
Disneyland since June 2011 and our second stay at Homewood. I regretted not staying there in for Christmas/New Years. For the extra $100 it would have been worth it to me to not be at an ART hotel. There have been some hit/miss reviews on here lately. My last experience was great. I had no complaints and look forward to my trip (I love watching my countdown in my signature).
We can put the kids to bed and still relax and watch TV in the other room. We use the full fridge and microwave in the room. We went to Target and bought bottled water and soda. We put the water in the freezer to take the to park the next day. I bought a frozen pizza for a late night snack and microwave popcorn. We found the breakfast to be perfect for our family. We also enjoyed the light meals with beer and wine Monday - Thursday. The dedicated shuttle is a great feature too. It was on time and reliable. I won't stay at another ART hotel - ever.
Another benefit for me staying at the Homewood is you can sign up for Hilton Rewards. It's not a credit card. Just like a rewards card you would get at the grocery store. I book my hotel directly thru their website. I earned triple points for my stay on this trip and will have enough points for about 5 more nights. From a financial perspective that's a no brainer for me. You may want to look into it.
Marriott offers reward points too so if you go that route you should look into it. It might allow you to visit again.
We are staying at the HOJO in November. It will be our first time staying there. I've heard good things and look forward to checking it out. We were able to get the AP rate before they changed their policy. Personally, I don't think it is a great value at their regular prices. Especially considering it doesn't include a free breakfast or the evening light meal. I would only consider staying there at a promotional rate.