You just might be right. We walked all around the whole resort when we stayed there last summer, and it's just a lovely walk, but we wondered about the Carousel section. It was still under construction then, but our thought was that it would make sense to reduce the point cost per night for that last building especially, or the whole Carousel section, which might cause people to actually request it if point savings were the goal.
Too late. That ship has already sailed.
The
point charts determine how many points
DVC can sell for each unit and at least one of the buildings in The Carousel is already sold out. To reduce the number of points now would be reducing the ownership percentage of each person who legally owns a part of that building, and that's a big no-no.
There may be some complicated hoops DVC could jump thru to transfer ownership to another building, but if they had any inclination of charging less for that location, they would have done it already.
Probably the most we could ever hope for would be guaranteed resort location at the time of booking. BWV has "Preferred Pool / Garden" and "Preferred Boardwalk View" categories with the same nightly points requirement. That two-tiered system has only been in place for a few years and it was done as a result of years of guest complaints--I would guess that almost every person booking the preferred view would request a BW view, and only about 1/3 of them actually received it.
It would take a pretty big uprising among SSR owners to force that sort of a change, and I don't see that happening.
I'd like to think that someday DVC will upgrade its computers so as to guarantee things like smoking preference and resort location. But that sort of change would add cost to the process. Example:
"I got the last Studio at SSR but it was a Smoking Room in The Carousel. I went on the waitlist for Non-Smoking or a room in The Springs or Congress Park"
"My NS waitlist came thru, but I'm still waiting for The Springs or Congress Park."
"I got a NS room in Congress Park, but The Springs is my ideal location so I'll stay on the waitlist...."
...and so on. If they get too specific in adding guarantees to the reservation, what began as a guaranteed Studio reservation with requests for NS and Congress Park has morphed into something that required 3-4 modifications.
But we can always hope...