BrianL
Doom Buggy Driver
- Joined
- Jul 24, 2013
- Messages
- 26,484
I did not read the whole arc so I can't really comment on details. I do agree that in real life not everyone from an ethnicity is just good or just bad. And that dictatorships are bad in general.
I can also tell you as a minority, Magneto at his core was right. Why keep groveling at their oppresors when they could just make their own fantastical utopia.Of course that would never work in real life, but the Xmen don't live in real life. It is fictional wish fulfillment
![]()
Magneto has murdered thousands - possibly more. His actions have never been justified. And he didn't really want to just self-segregate, he wanted to rule. His motives are not sympathetic.
Wish fulfillment and power fantasies are one thing, but making all the characters sanctimonious jerks, even toward their friends and people who have supported them in the past (i.e. the Fantastic Four) is a mistake. Their ethno-centrist nation was depicted as somewhere between Apartheid-era South Africa and Nazi Germany. Just because it was humans they were discriminating against, doesn't make those comparisons any better.
Also, it was revealed that Xavier's favortie movie was Song of the South, so....
