We've eaten at Shutters several times and always enjoyed our meals there. We just returned from a trip last week and ate at Shutters- we enjoyed our meal there again.
DH had the smoked prime rib with Shutters potatoes. We said both were delicious and that the prime rib was cooked perfectly and was a very generous portion and was the best prime rib he's had on property. He had the ceasar salad appetizer and said that was good as well.
I had the coconut shrimp w/island slaw as an appetizer and it was wonderful. What I usually don't like about coconut shrimp elsewhere is that it just tastes like fried shrimp and not "coconutty" enough. Well here I could definitely taste the coconut, and the island slaw had a little sweetness with a bit of mango thrown in- delicious. For the entree I had the Salmon BLT- pan seared salmon on top of a salad of arugula, tomatoes, and smoked applewood bacon. It was also delicious! The salmon had a nice sear on the outside, nicely crisp, but still perfectly tender on the inside. It was also a very generous portion of salmon.
For dessert, DH had the cheesecake w/strawberries, and I had the key lime tart. Again both were very good.
I will say the restaurant itself isn't as pretty as others, but we go there for the food and great tropical drinks (Caribbean Smugglers and Banana Cabanas- mmmmmm!). Go ahead and try it- there are always differing opinions on here about restaurants... what works for some may not work for others.