Should This Judge continue to Serve?

DawnCt1

<font color=red>I had to wonder what "holiday" he
Joined
May 17, 2004
Messages
30,053
Judge Cofield was arrested on a DUI. She was taken into custody and videotaped. She was rude, unruly and perhaps quite drunk. Since then she has been accepted into the Accelerated Rehabilitation Program, which dictates that after she completes the requirements, her record is erased and she is given a second chance. She was accepted into that program PRIOR to the release of that tape, which calls into the question the police department's motivation in releasing a tape which violates the privacy of the program. In addition, it is widely said, according to a morning radio announcer, that every lawyer who he has spoken to off the record, says she is a fair and decent judge with exemplary court room demeanor. Should she be removed? My feeling is, since she was accepted into the AR Program, those making that decision must have seen enough redeeming qualities to give her a second chance. Is reviewing her behavior in relationship to that same arrest a violation of that agreement? There is a move to remove her from the bench.
http://www.courant.com/community/news/ec/hc-cofield0127.artjan27,0,7271309.story
Repeatedly using vulgar and racial insults, Superior Court Judge E. Curtissa Cofield argued with a police officer — addressing him as "Negro trooper" at one point — who was trying to process her on a charge of drunken driving in Glastonbury last October, a police video released Monday shows.

Cofield also is heard twice on the video using the racial term "n-----."

The state's Judicial Review Council released the video Monday after it found cause to pursue five judicial misconduct charges against her, several of them based on what was termed disparaging, demeaning or "racially inappropriate" language.

The council has scheduled a hearing Feb. 9 to determine whether Cofield violated the judicial code of conduct and, if so, what action to take against her.



The video shows an uncooperative Cofield continually interrupting state police Sgt. Dwight Washington, who was asking a series of questions while processing her on the DUI charge at the Glastonbury police headquarters.

At 2:17 a.m. on Oct. 10, nearly two hours into the booking at headquarters, Cofield is seated at a desk and calls her husband on her cellphone. Washington, who like Cofield is black, is standing about 3 feet away.

Her end of the conversation, in part, is: "I don't need a ride home. ... I'm a criminal. ... What? What? ... Well, they got the head n----- in charge and he … Which one, the head n----- in charge? … Washington. OK. That's H-N-I-G...."

Then she hands the phone to Washington, who talks to her husband about getting the car off the highway. Washington asks, "Do you guys have Triple-A?"

Hearing that, Cofield interjects: "Oh, no. We don't. We're ghetto Negroes. We don't have Triple-A."

Earlier, when asked if she was injured, Cofield replied: "Yeah, I am. I'm humiliated by your f-----g attitude."

Asked if she was ill, Cofield replied, "I'm sick of being treated like a freaking Negro from the 'hood," and added: "Write it down, write it. Did you hear what I just said?"

Asked what her illness was, Cofield said: "Negro-itis."

"Do you need to take any medication now?" Washington asked.

"Yeah, I need to take anti-Negro, ummm ..."

When he asked what she weighed, Cofield replied: "Why don't you look at me, tell what you think?"

Asked how much alcohol she had had that day, Cofield replied: "I had no alcohol to drink, Mr. Washington."

Cofield often talked over Washington as he tried to question her, saying again and again that she needed to go to the bathroom. Washington politely insisted that she answer the questions first, and said that she could get to the bathroom sooner if she did so.

"That's your interpretation, but we'll see what they say in court, won't we, Mr. Washington?" she said.

Washington asked if she was willing to take an intoxication test. She replied: "Mr. Negro Washington. I need to go to the bathroom, and then I will take the test."

"It's Sgt. Washington," he replied, adding, "Don't disrespect me, and I won't disrespect you."

At another moment, after she had given a urine sample, Cofield asked Washington: "Do you have a reading on my urine test, Negro trooper?"

When asked to sign a form that she understood her rights, Cofield said, "I'm not signing anything, because when it comes down to the bottom line, who's smarter — me or you? We'll figure it out, won't we?"

Asked if she took any drugs, Cofield responded: "Oh, yeah, I'm a crack addict. Do I look like that to you?"

Then she directed her attention to the first state trooper on the scene of her accident and asked him, "Can you tell me why you came first, and then you had to bring him [Washington]? Is it because you had to make this valid by bringing a Negro?"

Cofield was originally appointed in 1991 as the state's first black female judge after Gov. Lowell P. Weicker Jr. nominated her and legislators confirmed her. She was last renominated by Gov. M. Jodi Rell and approved by lawmakers in 2007. Her current term expires on June 6, 2015.

Cofield apologized Dec. 8 at Superior Court in Manchester for sideswiping a state police car with her BMW, and was accepted into an alcohol education program. If she successfully completes the program, the charges — driving under the influence and failure to drive in the proper lane — will be dismissed.

About 10:45 p.m. on Oct. 9, Cofield, 60, was driving through a highway construction zone on Route 2 in Glastonbury when her car sideswiped a parked state police cruiser occupied by Trooper Michael Kowal. Prosecutor John Whalen said that the judge's eyes were bloodshot and that she smelled of alcohol. Urine samples showed her blood alcohol content was 0.16 percent at 1 a.m. on Oct. 10 and 0.17 percent at 2:04 a.m., he said — twice the legal limit of 0.08 percent.

State legislators had been hoping to view the video, and now will be able to do so and consider whatever decision the Judicial Review Council makes. Rep. Michael Lawlor, D-East Haven, co-chairman of the legislative judicial committee, has said that lawmakers could theoretically seek Cofield's removal.

He said Monday he believes that the council "will consider whether to recommend that she be removed as a judge. ... I think in many ways the ball is in Judge Cofield's court to convince them that she deserves to remain on the bench. I think if any legislator, any judge, any prosecutor, any police officer, did the exact same thing ... they probably would end up losing their job."

Courant Staff Writer David Owens contributed to this story.
Email
 
I feel bad for the troopers. It sounds like she carries a lot of serious baggage.
 
Well if rapist and murderers get the chance to be rehabilitated and released back out into the workforce, why shouldn't a drunk judge get the same chance?
 
Can her words be considered "racist"? Should the police have released a video tape of the incident after she was accepted into AR? The arrest took place some time ago. The video was released to the public/media this weekend.
 

Her words were racial. I don't know if they were racist. Would she have said these things sober? And would she have meant them?

It is sad that a well-respected judge took a public fall. The big question is, how has she responded since the tape was released? Was she indignant or remorseful?
 
Her words were racial. I don't know if they were racist. Would she have said these things sober? And would she have meant them?

It is sad that a well-respected judge took a public fall. The big question is, how has she responded since the tape was released? Was she indignant or remorseful?

She is now facing a misconduct hearing based on this incident. From previous accounts she is embarrassed and contrite. It seems to me that the release of the video, the misconduct hearing, etc is piling on to a situation that was/is in the process of being addressed. This seems not unlike the situation with Mel Gibson who was arrested on a DUI, made inappropriate racial comments, etc. He was branded a racist for them.
 
She is now facing a misconduct hearing based on this incident. From previous accounts she is embarrassed and contrite. It seems to me that the release of the video, the misconduct hearing, etc is piling on to a situation that was/is in the process of being addressed. This seems not unlike the situation with Mel Gibson who was arrested on a DUI, made inappropriate racial comments, etc. He was branded a racist for them.

I'm discovering that the application of "racist" is oddly selective.
 
I'm discovering that the application of "racist" is oddly selective.

I hesitate to call her statements racist because

1- they weren't directed at someone of a different race and

2 - more importantly, they seemed to be more about herself than the black officer. Like I said in my first post, it seems as if she has some self-hate. That is sad.
 
The word racist is being bandied about here locally. Some see her language as inhibiting her ability to be fair from the bench.
 

Why? If by all reports, she has been a fair and just judge, has conducted herself in an exemplary fashion in all of her professional duties, AND was accepted into the AR program so her record will ultimately be sealed if she completes the requirements, why should she lose her job? Her behavior was related to her condition (drunk) at the time of arrest. She didn't plead "not guilty", she agreed to the conditions set by the court. Why shouldn't she get a second chance at her life?
 
and if she where white?...............................
 
She was drunk. How many of us here have either done it ourselves or known/seen people that have had to much to drink and then say and do stupid things?

It happens. Doesn't mean it's right, but that is just what drunk people do. They make fools of themselves, the talk big, they act tough, they say things they would never say sober. Whiskey courage.

I think that is the case here. If, prior to her DUI arrest, she has performed her duties as a judge without complaint then she should be allowed to continue. She made a mistake and drove after having to much to drink. If this was a second offense or if there was some sort of pattern here, then her sitting on the bench should be looked at more closely. As it is though, let her continue with the AR program and let her continue on as a judge.
 
and if she where white?...............................

If she were white, I wonder if we would be having this discussion. I think she may have been forced to resign.
 
She was drunk. How many of us here have either done it ourselves or known/seen people that have had to much to drink and then say and do stupid things?

It happens. Doesn't mean it's right, but that is just what drunk people do. They make fools of themselves, the talk big, they act tough, they say things they would never say sober. Whiskey courage.

I think that is the case here. If, prior to her DUI arrest, she has performed her duties as a judge without complaint then she should be allowed to continue. She made a mistake and drove after having to much to drink. If this was a second offense or if there was some sort of pattern here, then her sitting on the bench should be looked at more closely. As it is though, let her continue with the AR program and let her continue on as a judge.

So was Mel Gibson, but that excuse didn't work to well for him.
 
So was Mel Gibson, but that excuse didn't work to well for him.

Well, I'm just calling it the way I see it. YMMV I just know I have seen drunk people do things they would never do sober and that may be the case here just as it may have been with Mel Gibson. None of us will ever know though if that is what is really going on with this judge or not. She could be a flaming racist at home, who knows?
 
If she is this much a racist, she should not be allowed to serve. :sad2:

Most drunks that I have seen don't seem to make very much sense. How do we know that she is a racist? What is more indicative? Her history of unflawed service or the ramblings of an intoxicated woman?
 
To me, the fact that she was irresponsible enough to drink and drive, an illegal activity, is enough to call for her removal from the bench. A judge should know better than this. By choosing to knowingly break the law, she made her bed.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom