should Disney remake BC?

[veggiop]

should Disney remake the Black Cauldron to follow the books more? would you like to see it live action or animated?

 

[kolohe_lady]

I love those books, so personally I'd be happy to see Disney try it again. Live action would be cool now that special effects technology has come so far.

 

[PhillyMc]

I'd like all the books but that would be quite an undertaking.

 

[themermaidgirl]

I LOVED the Black Cauldron animated film so I definitely do not want a remake.

 

[karly05]

Yes yes yessity yes yes!!! Please please please!!! Do it in live action, do all 5 books as faithfully as reasonably possible, and can I please have Mackenzie Crook as Fflewddur Fflam? That's my biggest beef with the animated version; FF is one of my all-time favorite fictional crushes, and he is not a bumbling old man! He's an adult in relation to Taran and Eilonwy, but young enough to tramp all over the country, and still be rather dashing in his lovable Fflam way, and he is supposed to be skinny and blond and long-nosed.

"Castle of Llyr" is my favorite, and with modern CGI, they could have so much fun with Llyan the cat; the Fflewddur/Llyan story in that book is my favorite stuff in the whole series.

 

[sailorstitch]

I really LOVE The Black Cauldron just the way it is. However, I can see the possibilites here. Since Tim Burton has been making some of the Disney movies into live action versions. And he did work on the animated version. I could see him doing a live action version of TBC. I don't know if i'd go see it. I'm not a fan of Tim Burton. But it could be possible.

sailorstitch

 

[ashvig]

should Disney remake the Black Cauldron to follow the books more? would you like to see it live action or animated?

I would like to see animated rather than action.