I would like to agree with the posters who suggested Citrico's, The Wave, Artist's Point and the Turf Club. I'd also like to add Sanaa for consideration. We go there for lunch at least once every trip and find it very pleasant. We only had dinner there once and that was a few years ago, so I can't really comment about dinner. We've been to Bistro de Paris several times, but all before they were on the meal plan.
I strongly agree with Uncleromulus' caution about Blue Zoo and Il Mulino. We've dined in both places when there was a convention in the hotel and it was as loud as any WDW restaurant that we've dined at. Very unpleasant since the noise seems to bounce in both of those places. In addition to the noise at Blue Zoo, the service was terrible so much so that the head waiter had to come over to take care of us. (We didn't ask, he could just see that we weren't being well taken care of.) We will try both of these restaurants again some time, but not right away. We did not have that problem at Shula's. It was a nice, quiet atmosphere there.