Serious question, is there something wrong with my brother?

Disney1fan2002

<font color=red>Like OMG the TF is SOO psyched to
Joined
Jun 21, 2002
Messages
12,072
I need some opinions. I am nor sure if I just think my brother is weird, because to me it is extreme, or if this is what many dad of little girls are like. I know my Dh is not like this.

My brother and his wife have an only child, a girl. She is going to be 6yo in January. This little girl is there universe. Her mother is a little obsessive about her, she has never been left with anyone....and they take her to every function/party they are invited to, regardless if kids are invited or NOT. My brother has ended up like his wife, which surprises myself and my other siblings, because we were raised in house full of 12 kids....so we know better than anyone, that you don't need to be around your kid 24/7.

Anyway, I could go on all night...but my big concern is the extreme my brother has gone. My BIL told me he had a conversation one day with my brother. He said my brother was going on and on and on about how he did not want his daughter to grow up and get a boyfriend. I know all dad don't like the thought of their little girls growing up, and some are real strict, but I don't know many who will start worrying when the child is only 5yo. My BIL just told him he needed to live for today, and let her be FIVE, and not worry about what may happen in 10-15years. I honestly think my brother loses sleep over the thought of her having a boyfriend.

Last night, I called my brother to see how is Christmas went. I asked about his DD, and he told me someone gave her, *gasp* MAKE-UP. Now, it is child make-up. But bother does not care. He is not happy about it at all. I tried calming him down, and rationalizing with him. I pointed out how our dad forbid us girls to wear make-up, and the result was, we would sneak it on outside of the house. I asked him if he wanted his daughter to sneak behind his back. I told him if he let her "play" with make-up now, the novelty of it will be worn off by the time she is a teenager, and she won't go overbaord with it. She will know how to use it, and they can help her learn the correct amount to wear. He would not hear of it. He was really mad. I change the subject.

We then start talking about TV shows the kids watch. His DD does not watch Full House, but he said she has to watch Fresh Prince of Bel Air. She loves that show. I said, without THINKING, that she probably has a little crush on Will Smith. ...WHOOPSIES. Wrong thing to say. I said it because I think it would be cute if she had a little crush on him. Well, that was too much for my brother. He was actually speechless.

How can I have normal conversations about the kids growing up, if he freaks out at every mention of his daughter growing up, in every sense of the word.

Do you know anyone like this, or is he in a class of his own? I have my own DD, and I can't imagine stressing and worrying about her teen years right now, she is only 7. I will have enough of that soon enough. Right now, I am enjoying her being 7.
 
dont worry, by the time she is a teenager he wont be able to stand her :teeth:
 
Pop daddy! Did you read that super long post? Wow, I feel sooo sexy! :teeth:
 

Disney1fan2002 said:
Pop daddy! Did you read that super long post? Wow, I feel sooo sexy! :teeth:

I skimmined, but baby you are turning me on :banana:
 
I don't think that is normal behavior. I would be concerned about the effect it will have on your niece. If they try to keep her a "little girl" she will have a lot of problems later in life. I wish I had some suggestions for you, the only thing I can think of is maybe a family intervention. This is a problem that will only get worse if nothing is done about the way they treat their child.
 
My BIL is like that too with his daughter, but with him, it's more of a control thing. He picks strange things to worry about and lay down strict rules about. But it comes and goes with his mood. The thing is...there's no point in your Brother obsessing about it. I can understand him not wanting the makeup, but all he has to do is stick it away somewhere. IMO...the bigger deal he makes of it the more she's going to want it. She's going to get older. It's inevitable.
 
Well this is a DAD of ONLY DD thing now mine 12 now does thing without us as we do thing ( VEGAS ) without her .I pick my battles and stick to them ( no 2 peice ,nothing on the backside of shorts or pants,no BoyF until 2nd yr HS) .

Now I try to include her friends in everywhere we take her including some boy from school and soccer as I feel if I can keep her occupied she will not fall into the bad bunch (and boy do we have that here14 yr olds pushing babys around).
 
Does seem a bit extreme to me. Is she is school yet? I have 3 girls and while my DH is a bit over protective...a lot more than me....he is not over controlling. Kids makeup? The girls loved it, they also used to like "playing" in my real makeup...boy did they look funny sometimes! Now my girls are all teens and they are not really into makeup all that much; a little powder, lipgloss and mascara. My 13 year old doesn't touch the stuff. Boy is he gonna have some problems when she gets older!
 
Pop Daddy said:
dont worry, by the time she is a teenager he wont be able to stand her :teeth:

Pop Daddy, you crack me up!!! :rotfl2: :rotfl2:

On a serious note though, I would be a little concerned if this my DB. He's going to smother this girl so much that when she's older she going to want to get the heck away from him :guilty:

I don't blame him for not wanting his DD to play with makeup, I don't like my DD playing with to much makeup either, but I certainly don't get irrate if someone gives it to her. The makeup just starts to slowly disappear over time ;)

I don't know if there's to much you are going to be able to do about his though because he naturally is not going to agree with you on his behavior. I would just say small things to him in conversations when the moments right to get him to start thinking about how ridiculous he is being, because a big conversation about it is not going to work - he'll probably just close his ears to the whole thing.

Good luck!!!
 
Sounds like your niece is a very lucky girl that her parents really love her more than anything in the world.
You can never be too much of a mother, or father.
That's the way DH and I always felt about DS, I don't think it's overprotective, I just think they ENJOY being with their daughter. I don't think there is a problem and think your brother is perfectly normal.

When you say he can't imagine her having boyfriends, that's because she's only 5 he will get used to it when she gets to that stage of life. What makes her happy will make him happy. Sometimes it's hard for parents to get used to the changes that go along with their children growing up, they want them to stay little forever!
It's very refreshing for me to hear there are other parents out there that feel the same as we do about our DS, who by the way is in college this year...yes it was hard on us! But we survived. Children that are brought up by very loving and concerned parents (AKA "Overprotective"), usually grow up to be Wonderful, Caring Adults, that are very family oriented!
 
Lynn CC said:
Sounds like your niece is a very lucky girl that her parents really love her more than anything in the world.
You can never be too much of a mother, or father.
That's the way DH and I always felt about DS, I don't think it's overprotective, I just think they ENJOY being with their daughter. I don't think there is a problem and think your brother is perfectly normal.

When you say he can't imagine her having boyfriends, that's because she's only 5 he will get used to it when she gets to that stage of life. What makes her happy will make him happy. Sometimes it's hard for parents to get used to the changes that go along with their children growing up, they want them to stay little forever!
It's very refreshing for me to hear there are other parents out there that feel the same as we do about our DS, who by the way is in college this year...yes it was hard on us! But we survived. Children that are brought up by very loving and concerned parents (AKA "Overprotective"), usually grow up to be Wonderful, Caring Adults, that are very family oriented!

Overprotective is one thing, but do you really think it's "normal" for a man to become "speechless" at the thought of his very young DD having a crush on a movie star?

If that were my husband, he'd be getting his head examined.
 
Marseeya said:
?

If that were my husband, he'd be getting his head examined.

I agree. His behavior seems rather strange to me.
 
We have three DDs (9, 7 and 4) and DH is very protective of them. They "play" with make up, but we do try to monitor what they watch on TV, especially messages on weight/body image and dating. They're kids, after all, and don't need to be inundated with diet ads or the pressure to date from the time they're 3!!! We've even turned off a Disney Channel Movie or two because they're just not appropriate. Don't even get me started on the commercials they show when they're airing a movie for kids. I think your brother's behavior is a little extreme, but I also understand that he wants to protect her. Kids shows are much more racy and violent than they used to be. I don't really understand letting her watch the Fresh Prince of Bel Air and not Full House though. LOL
 
Its extreme, and also hints at male chauvanism.

Sounds like if he has his way, his DD will be in the home "where a woman belongs" and won't be able to speak to a boy until she's 30!

I doubt he'd treat a son this way, and I sure hope he does not treat his wife this way. Is his wife "allowed" to look at tv shows with attractive men, or does that rule apply to her too? :rolleyes:
 
I think that this is extreme.

He has a problem with a little 5 year old playing dress-up and make-up!
What is he thinking???? She is just five.

He definately has some issues.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer

New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom