Oh, glad it's not a formal tasting! Like I said, I'm good with it either way, especially if it's reception-style.
The tastings I've been to have been fairly generous with the liquor, though it would've been nice if DCL had been a bit more forthcoming with the details on that. If we go with DCL, I'd suggest not fooling with the Pub Crawl date again as people have already had to change their plans once for it. If the Crawl is planned from 1:00-5:00, we could just crawl to the Champagne Girls meet at 3:00 and crawl back to the group afterwards. We will never find a day and time that doesn't conflict with someone's plans for something, even if we go with BYO.
I'd like to hear what the "veterans" of last year's Champagne Girls think. Will we be able to find a place to meet if decide to do a BYO meet? Will "party crashers" be a problem? We haven't had anyone volunteer a room (I would, but ours is a regular sized cabin and Dennis' socks will be on every seating place - eew), so I'm thinking we'd have to take over the Promenade lounge, a deck space, or the deck 7 aft space.
How do others feel about picking their own champagne? Personally, I know what I like and know a fair amount about wine, so I think BYO would be fun. But I can see people feeling intimidated about choosing something, to which I say...
When in doubt, pick something with a cute label and a fair price. You'd be surprised at how tasty some of the "cheap stuff" can be.
It would probably be more convenient to just go with the DCL plan, as long as everyone is okay with the details of it.
And Claire,
THANK YOU AGAIN for all your work, worry, and diligence in dealing with us and DCL. Not an easy task!