My thought when I started this thread was as a park complement (we own at Poly, so my next resort would be near HS or AK.) But I’m sure there are a lot of other variables that I haven’t thought of and would like to know so I can consider them.
Almost all of my life experience at WDW has been off-site and visiting MK. AK wasn’t around when I was young, my parents saw our sole EPCOT visit as a dud (albeit I now believe this is a reflection on them not EPCOT,) and HS was MGM when I first visited so I could see the Dick Tracy show.
I’m now trying to envision the next few decades and I know what works best now is likely to change over the years.
I’m curious what variables people consider beyond proximity and transportation options to each park.
Just my opinion, but if I were in your shoes, regardless of when you add on, I would give heavy consideration to complimenting your monorail resort location with Boardwalk or Beach Club points. Yes, there are
only 2 decades left, but by then your kids will likely be living their own lives, and the benefit of being able to roll out of bed and be at both Epcot and HS entrances with a 10-15 minute walk can not be understated!
In addition, the fun activities on the Boardwalk for both families and adults is unlike any other resort. Add to that the numerous dining options within walking distance (at Epcot, Boardwalk, Yacht & Beach Clubs and Swan & Dolphin resorts) makes for a terrific vacation destination.
I am somewhat biased as we have been BWV owners for 20+ years but the convenience factor is such an advantage, leading to more flexible and relaxing vacations. Due to the 2042 expiration these 2 resorts are certainly not the “best deal”, but time is money in my book, and we have literally saved hours each day on our WDW vacations over the years by not having to take buses (or a car) to these 2 parks. And resale contracts might also be an option for these resorts in order to make it more economical. Just something to consider.
I do agree with others however - waiting until you have had a chance to stay at any resorts you are considering could be very beneficial.
Enjoy your stays and Welcome Home!
