I was looking at Scutes and Niles. Went with the Niles. They look like prison shower shoes (ok, no, I dont have firsthand experience!). They are not uncomfortable, tho not as comfortable as my Payless Airwalks. Which I love!!! So heres what I did---got a pair of Airwalks- and in about 30 seconds cut off the toe portion. Now I have a supercomfortable pair of Niles type shoes. I love 'em!!
Note: in Payless I also got a pair of Keen knock offs--25 bucks! and a kind of Croc knock off but with a pull tie kind of thing, for DH. He already loves his Airwalk Beach knock offs...