I got both. I wore them every day until I lost them. Oddly enough, I lost both of them in a very similar way.
I lost my high school ring while I was in college. I was washing my hands before lunch one day when the ring slid off and went down the drain.
I lost my college ring about a year after I finished college. Again, washing my hands, but I took the ring off this time (lesson learned, I thought). The ring bounced off the floor, up under the sink cabinet. I tried and tried to get it, but never could get it out from underneath!