Royal wedding and social class in UK - question for British DIS'ers

I'm sorry but I find the conjecture about her intentions quite odd. Kate has been very reserved in discussing the relationship and her friends have also been discreet.

Anyway, this is nothing new: Sarah Ferguson and Sophie Rhys-Jones were also "commoners" prior to their marriages, as indeed was Diana. Sophie's background was quite similar to Kate's. One thing I've noticed during the past few days: I think I've heard the term "commoner" used only a couple of times during British TV coverage over the past few days but I've heard it used quite frequently during the "E!" channel coverage. But I suspect E! likes a cliche as much as the Daily Mail...

I don't like the term social climber but I think my mum (R.I.P) would have found it hysterical to be classed as one, having been born in to a working class family and ending up middle class. Which makes me off-spring of a social climber. I need to go now, I have a date with Torquil Farquharson-Buccleugh. ;)

Diana was not a commoner. Her family had a title. Her family didn;t have much money, but her Father, and now her brother have the title Earl. Just saying...
 
I'm sorry but I find the conjecture about her intentions quite odd. Kate has been very reserved in discussing the relationship and her friends have also been discreet.

Anyway, this is nothing new: Sarah Ferguson and Sophie Rhys-Jones were also "commoners" prior to their marriages, as indeed was Diana. Sophie's background was quite similar to Kate's. One thing I've noticed during the past few days: I think I've heard the term "commoner" used only a couple of times during British TV coverage over the past few days but I've heard it used quite frequently during the "E!" channel coverage. But I suspect E! likes a cliche as much as the Daily Mail...

I don't like the term social climber but I think my mum (R.I.P) would have found it hysterical to be classed as one, having been born in to a working class family and ending up middle class. Which makes me off-spring of a social climber. I need to go now, I have a date with Torquil Farquharson-Buccleugh. ;)

I don't think Lady Diana could be classified as a 'commoner'. She was the daughter of Earl Spencer and Frances Shand Kydd. Her father was the Viscount Althorp and later the 8th Earl Spencer. Frances Shand Kydd, her mother and herself the daughter of Edmund Roche, 4th Baron Fermoy, was born at Sandringham. Diana Spencer was a descendant of Charles II through four illegitimate sons and a descendant of James II through an illegitimate daughter. Her great-grandmother, Frances Work, was an American heiress.

So, I'd say nobility-class with royal roots (even if they were from the wrong side of the sheets).

agnes!
PS - I just thinl they met and fell in love and wish them nothing but the best.
 
Diana was a commoner prior to marriage because she was not royalty. She was born in to an aristocratic family, but not the Royal Family. I remember that being discussed on the telly when I was a child.
 
Diana was not a commoner. Her family had a title. Her family didn;t have much money, but her Father, and now her brother have the title Earl. Just saying...

I used to think that too, but apparently, having a title does not make you not a commoner.

From Wikipedia:

In British law, a commoner is someone who is neither the Sovereign nor a peer. Therefore, any member of the Royal Family who is not a peer, such as Prince Harry of Wales or Anne, Princess Royal, is a commoner, as is any member of a peer's family, including someone who holds only a courtesy title, such as the Earl of Arundel and Surrey (eldest son of the Duke of Norfolk) or Lady Victoria Hervey (a daughter of the 6th Marquess of Bristol).
 
In one of those news specials it was mentioned that when she was a teenager she had a poster of Wills hanging in her room and something was mentioned about her wanting to marry him someday. I think it was in the Katie Couric special.

So I would say that possibly her goal *could* have been to meet, woo, and marry the future king. Why is that so unbelievable? :confused3
 
I don't care what anyone else says, Lady Diana was a member of the aristocracy or nobility and not a 'commoner'.

Sheesh, everyone except the Monarch and immediate family are commoners?...technically might be true, but I don't care.

And anyone can edit Wikipedia.

agnes!
 
I don't care what anyone else says, Lady Diana was a member of the aristocracy or nobility and not a 'commoner'.

Sheesh, everyone except the Monarch and immediate family are commoners?...technically might be true, but I don't care.

And anyone can edit Wikipedia.

agnes!

And it is explained in the previously cited article from The Guardian:

Lady Diana Spencer, lest we forget, the daughter of a viscount who was Queen Mary's godson, was technically a commoner. Anne Hyde, who married the future James II in 1660 and whose daughters, Mary and Anne, both became queen, was the daughter of a barrister and MP, but was raised in royal circles as her father was a close confidant of Charles I and was maid of honour to the king's sister when she married. Elizabeth Woodville, queen consort of Edward IV, also fell outside the European royal line, qualifying her as another commoner; her father, however, was an earl.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/apr/30/royal-wedding-monarchy
 
In one of those news specials it was mentioned that when she was a teenager she had a poster of Wills hanging in her room and something was mentioned about her wanting to marry him someday. I think it was in the Katie Couric special.

So I would say that possibly her goal *could* have been to meet, woo, and marry the future king. Why is that so unbelievable? :confused3

That I think is one of the things the press got hold off and ran with, which Kate has said it was untrue.

Both Kate and Wills were friends before they dated and he actually dated some of her friends before. It was only after that fashion show he saw her in a different light. She was also the person who gave him the advice to stay at University and complete his degree.
 
Yes, technically Diana was a commoner, which simply means that you are not the Sovereign or a Peer. While her father and then her brother were/are peers, she herself was not; the "Lady" was a courtesy title that she received as the daughter of an Earl. I think that a lot of people equate "commoner" with "not an aristocrat", but the real definition is narrower than that. You can be an aristocrat and still legally be a commoner.

The "big deal" status of being a non-aristocrat and marrying into the British ruling house is directly proportional to how close you are to the throne. It was still a huge deal when Anne married Mark Phillips, because at the time she was 4th in the order of succession. By the time Edward married he had dropped from 3rd down to 8th. Changes in attitude have made a big difference today, but so has medical progress -- people live longer now and are less likely to die young of natural causes. (Remember that the last two British kings both started out as second sons; antibiotics have been invented since.)
 
In one of those news specials it was mentioned that when she was a teenager she had a poster of Wills hanging in her room and something was mentioned about her wanting to marry him someday. I think it was in the Katie Couric special.

So I would say that possibly her goal *could* have been to meet, woo, and marry the future king. Why is that so unbelievable? :confused3

Can't we all remember our preteen and teenage years when we had posters on the bedroom walls of all the singers and actors and what not that we thought were cute? Oh, how we dreamed of meeting them, falling madly in love and marrying them. :love:

I'm sure there were thousands of English girls that had his poster on their walls also. Doesn't make Kate a gold digger or social climber though. Just means that she was like all the other girls her age. :confused3

I don't see how she could have set it up. To meet him, room with him and force him to fall in love with her. Was it her teenage dream? Maybe, and lucky girl, it came true. Nothing wrong with that. Doesn't make her a social climber or gold digger or anything. Just makes her a girl with hormones. Heck, she could have met him, roomed with him and realized that she hated him. :confused3
 
That I think is one of the things the press got hold off and ran with, which Kate has said it was untrue.

Both Kate and Wills were friends before they dated and he actually dated some of her friends before. It was only after that fashion show he saw her in a different light. She was also the person who gave him the advice to stay at University and complete his degree.

THe poster in her room? Really? How many young girls her age had a poster of prince william? How many would fantasize about being married to him? I am willing to bet A LOT id not MOST all of the girls her age did.

Harley I agree with you
 
Can't we all remember our preteen and teenage years when we had posters on the bedroom walls of all the singers and actors and what not that we thought were cute? Oh, how we dreamed of meeting them, falling madly in love and marrying them. :love:

I'm sure there were thousands of English girls that had his poster on their walls also. Doesn't make Kate a gold digger or social climber though. Just means that she was like all the other girls her age. :confused3
I don't see how she could have set it up. To meet him, room with him and force him to fall in love with her. Was it her teenage dream? Maybe, and lucky girl, it came true. Nothing wrong with that. Doesn't make her a social climber or gold digger or anything. Just makes her a girl with hormones. Heck, she could have met him, roomed with him and realized that she hated him. :confused3


I never implied that she was. I was just relaying what *I* remember from a news story last week.
 
If you ask me, the Middletons far outclassed the Royals at the wedding. They were classily dressed and wonderfully composed. While William is dashing, Princess Beatrice's hat says so much to me about the ridiculousness of the British class system. Seriously, Bea is of higher society than Kate or Pippa?
 
I never implied that she was. I was just relaying what *I* remember from a news story last week.

Oh, I know. I was referencing the comments in the media and elsewhere that Kate is a social climber and gold digger. I know you weren't meaning that in your post. Sorry if it came across that way.
 
Can't we all remember our preteen and teenage years when we had posters on the bedroom walls of all the singers and actors and what not that we thought were cute? Oh, how we dreamed of meeting them, falling madly in love and marrying them. :love:

I'm sure there were thousands of English girls that had his poster on their walls also. Doesn't make Kate a gold digger or social climber though. Just means that she was like all the other girls her age. :confused3

I don't see how she could have set it up. To meet him, room with him and force him to fall in love with her. Was it her teenage dream? Maybe, and lucky girl, it came true. Nothing wrong with that. Doesn't make her a social climber or gold digger or anything. Just makes her a girl with hormones. Heck, she could have met him, roomed with him and realized that she hated him. :confused3

Yep at 15 I was going to run away to Seattle and Marry Eddie Vedder or Evan Dando and be sooo cool. Not sure how I would of got from London to Seattle or where, I would of stayed or what I would of done for money but aside from that it was a good plan! :rotfl:

I've just shown my age, haven't I? :blush:
 
PS - I just thinl they met and fell in love and wish them nothing but the best.

I agree-- I think this idea of her scheming to meet him and make him fall in love with her is a weird conspiracy theory. I guess people aren't content just to believe two lovely people fell in love. :confused3 There's not always "something else."
 
It probably also depends upon what class you're already in. If your (in British accent) in the Registry, then you may think, oh so tacky these commoners coming into their own. But if you are a muggle, you probably are thinking, you go girl.
 
In their engagement interview she was asked if she had had William's poster up - she didn't - it was a poster of the Levi's guy!
 
It probably also depends upon what class you're already in. If your (in British accent) in the Registry, then you may think, oh so tacky these commoners coming into their own. But if you are a muggle, you probably are thinking, you go girl.

Can you narrow down which accent? I'm English, I'm from London and I'm working class, I talk more like Eliza Doolittle than Hugh Grant! :flower3:

I also think she's stunning and from what I've seen they look genuinely in love and I wish them all the best.
 
It probably also depends upon what class you're already in. If your (in British accent) in the Registry, then you may think, oh so tacky these commoners coming into their own. But if you are a muggle, you probably are thinking, you go girl.

I thought we were talking about the British monarchy, not the British World of Wizards?

ETA: Sorry, I am reading Book 7 again and I couldn't resist.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom