Dancing_Nancy
Mouseketeer
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2009
- Messages
- 76
I know that so many have speculated about choosing DCL or RCCL. Ive also seen many posts comparing the two cruises. In the last year my family has cruised both (once on the Dream and just recently on the Freedom of the Seas). Granted, the Dream was a 4-night and the Freedom was a 7-night, but I thought I would just add my review to whoever might find it helpful.
First off, both cruises were wonderful. Anything that I might include as a criticism does not take away from the fantastic experience we had on both vacations. We experience great things and then some not-so-perfect things on every vacation (wherever it is), but that doesnt take away from the blessing of spending time with family and friends away from home.
On both cruises our immediate family (me and my wifeboth 33; and three children2 boys ages 9 & 6 and 1 daughter age 3) traveled with some members of our extended family. However, my review will pertain only to our immediate family and our personal opinions and experiences. Onto the review
CHECK-IN & CHECK OUT Whenever we cruise Disney, we always choose to purchase DCL transfers and take them from the airport to the port. We try to arrive at the airport to check-in and receive our boarding number fairly early (around 9 or 10), then catch the shuttle so that when we arrive at Port Canaveral our wait time is minimal. Our experience with RCCL was completely different. We stayed at Titusville the night before the cruise, then headed to the terminal around 11:00. By the time we arrived there were huge lines outside the terminal filled with people trying to get in. We stood in the heat for about 40 minutes. By the time we got inside to security, only one metal detector was being used (for what reason I dont know). Our family was actually the first family to start using the second metal detector so I assume the line started moving much quicker after that. Of course, then we went upstairs to check-in and found another huge line waiting for us. Thankfully, we were directed to the much shorter priority check-in line because our oldest son was staying in his grandparents room and they wanted to make sure everything was documented. I have to say I was very surprised by the less-than-stellar check-in system. Check-out was a similar process. Lots of lines and waiting. CHECK-IN & CHECK-OUT ADVANTAGE DISNEY.
FOOD We were very pleased with the food options on both cruises. We enjoy ordering breakfast at Royal Palace on Disney instead of hitting the buffet. At first when we went to the main dining room on Freedom to order breakfast we were disappointed. All you could order was Eggs Benedict or an omelet everything else was on a small buffet. However, someone else in our group told us that we should try the breakfast buffet upstairs at the Windjammer so we did the next morning and all the mornings after that! The Windjammer Buffet was GREAT! Our family loved it and found lots of good food to eat every morning. So in many ways, Breakfast was a toss-up between the two lines. As was lunchthe buffets are both outstanding with many options that will certainly please anyone.
The one difference was at dinner. My wife and I both agreed that the service and the quality of food at dinner in the main dining areas was better on the Dream. Again, thats not to say we didnt enjoy the food on Freedom. Our servers were fine, the selection was good, and we LOVED the lobster night. But if we had to give an edge to one it would most definitely be Disney. Disney just seemed to be a little more gourmet, a little classier, and a step up. Every night our menus had food stains on them and the corners were showing wear. Our servers on RCCL complained to us about the group that was in 2nd seating, which I thought was a little out of line. There was only one night that we thought dessert was outstanding. Again, nothing bad and no one complainedwe had a great time. But if I had to choose one dinner to attend it would be on the DREAM.
KIDS CLUBS This one surprised me. I have no idea why, but after doing one session of the Kids Clubs on the Dream, our kids werent interested in going back. But on the Freedom, they wanted to go all the time! It was one of the highlights for them. We were impressed with the activities, staff, and rooms. Checking in and out was a piece of cake. And all activities seemed to be age-appropriate. Advantage: FREEDOM.
ENTERTAINMENT I wouldnt classify our family as Disney-freaks, but we really do love Disney. All of the shows weve seen on our three DCL cruises have been fantastic. We especially love Believe. So I was fairly nervous about the entertainment onboard the Freedom. But my nerves quickly took a back seat! Our family attended all three of the major production shows: Marquee (Broadway style revue); the Magicianincredible!; and Once Upon A Time. Each was excellent and all three of our kids loved them too. The theater is great on both ships not really a bad seat in the house. I only wish the shows were a little bit longer Advantage: TOSS-UP
POOLS Since our kids are the ages they are, we obviously spent a lot of time at the pool on both ships. Clearly, this is where RCCL trumps Disney. I know there have been scads of reviews that describe the design flaws of the pool deck on the Dream and Fantasy and they are true. The pools and adjacent decks on the Disney ships are too small for the amount of passengers. I hope Disney addresses this in the future. However, on the Freedom the pools are much larger, plus there is the huge H20 Splash Zone for the kids. Our kids were happy to bounce back and forth between both areas. Finding chairs in the morning was not a problem on the Freedom. By the afternoon on the Days at Sea the decks were pretty full, but not uncomfortable as they are on DCL ships. Plus there are many more hot tubs for all to share. Clear Advantage: FREEDOM.
STATEROOMS We were in an inside stateroom on the Dream and an outside view room on the Freedom. Each room was fine for our needs and our room stewards were both outstanding.
MISCELANNEOUS One thing we noticed on the Freedom is that there seemed to be more to do at night if you werent going to go to the show. The Royal Promenade always had something going on, there seemed to be lots of things happening on the pool deck, there were many lounges and corners with singing, karaoke, trivia, etc , and of course there is the casino. When we cruise Disney, it seems as if the main event each night is the showwhich as I said we lovebut there doesnt seem to be much more action apart from that. At least its not in the open. And to be honest, Im really OK with that. Were the kind of family that can be very content to walk around the deck after the show then heading in for bed after a long day in the sun. But there was something fun about all the activity happening at night on the Freedom too. I guess thats a TOSS-UP, but something to consider if/when you decide to book.
Again, please know this review was not designed to say one cruise was bad and the other was good. I would sail on both lines again in the future (in fact, were already booked again on two cruises: DCL in 2013 and RCCL in 2014!!!). But hopefully this may help you as you decide whats best for your family.
Let me also say thank you to all who post on the boards. This is truly a wonderful forum and youve made all of our Disney trips so much better because of your input and tips. If you have any questions, I'd be glad to try to answer anything.
Happy Cruising!
First off, both cruises were wonderful. Anything that I might include as a criticism does not take away from the fantastic experience we had on both vacations. We experience great things and then some not-so-perfect things on every vacation (wherever it is), but that doesnt take away from the blessing of spending time with family and friends away from home.
On both cruises our immediate family (me and my wifeboth 33; and three children2 boys ages 9 & 6 and 1 daughter age 3) traveled with some members of our extended family. However, my review will pertain only to our immediate family and our personal opinions and experiences. Onto the review
CHECK-IN & CHECK OUT Whenever we cruise Disney, we always choose to purchase DCL transfers and take them from the airport to the port. We try to arrive at the airport to check-in and receive our boarding number fairly early (around 9 or 10), then catch the shuttle so that when we arrive at Port Canaveral our wait time is minimal. Our experience with RCCL was completely different. We stayed at Titusville the night before the cruise, then headed to the terminal around 11:00. By the time we arrived there were huge lines outside the terminal filled with people trying to get in. We stood in the heat for about 40 minutes. By the time we got inside to security, only one metal detector was being used (for what reason I dont know). Our family was actually the first family to start using the second metal detector so I assume the line started moving much quicker after that. Of course, then we went upstairs to check-in and found another huge line waiting for us. Thankfully, we were directed to the much shorter priority check-in line because our oldest son was staying in his grandparents room and they wanted to make sure everything was documented. I have to say I was very surprised by the less-than-stellar check-in system. Check-out was a similar process. Lots of lines and waiting. CHECK-IN & CHECK-OUT ADVANTAGE DISNEY.
FOOD We were very pleased with the food options on both cruises. We enjoy ordering breakfast at Royal Palace on Disney instead of hitting the buffet. At first when we went to the main dining room on Freedom to order breakfast we were disappointed. All you could order was Eggs Benedict or an omelet everything else was on a small buffet. However, someone else in our group told us that we should try the breakfast buffet upstairs at the Windjammer so we did the next morning and all the mornings after that! The Windjammer Buffet was GREAT! Our family loved it and found lots of good food to eat every morning. So in many ways, Breakfast was a toss-up between the two lines. As was lunchthe buffets are both outstanding with many options that will certainly please anyone.
The one difference was at dinner. My wife and I both agreed that the service and the quality of food at dinner in the main dining areas was better on the Dream. Again, thats not to say we didnt enjoy the food on Freedom. Our servers were fine, the selection was good, and we LOVED the lobster night. But if we had to give an edge to one it would most definitely be Disney. Disney just seemed to be a little more gourmet, a little classier, and a step up. Every night our menus had food stains on them and the corners were showing wear. Our servers on RCCL complained to us about the group that was in 2nd seating, which I thought was a little out of line. There was only one night that we thought dessert was outstanding. Again, nothing bad and no one complainedwe had a great time. But if I had to choose one dinner to attend it would be on the DREAM.
KIDS CLUBS This one surprised me. I have no idea why, but after doing one session of the Kids Clubs on the Dream, our kids werent interested in going back. But on the Freedom, they wanted to go all the time! It was one of the highlights for them. We were impressed with the activities, staff, and rooms. Checking in and out was a piece of cake. And all activities seemed to be age-appropriate. Advantage: FREEDOM.
ENTERTAINMENT I wouldnt classify our family as Disney-freaks, but we really do love Disney. All of the shows weve seen on our three DCL cruises have been fantastic. We especially love Believe. So I was fairly nervous about the entertainment onboard the Freedom. But my nerves quickly took a back seat! Our family attended all three of the major production shows: Marquee (Broadway style revue); the Magicianincredible!; and Once Upon A Time. Each was excellent and all three of our kids loved them too. The theater is great on both ships not really a bad seat in the house. I only wish the shows were a little bit longer Advantage: TOSS-UP
POOLS Since our kids are the ages they are, we obviously spent a lot of time at the pool on both ships. Clearly, this is where RCCL trumps Disney. I know there have been scads of reviews that describe the design flaws of the pool deck on the Dream and Fantasy and they are true. The pools and adjacent decks on the Disney ships are too small for the amount of passengers. I hope Disney addresses this in the future. However, on the Freedom the pools are much larger, plus there is the huge H20 Splash Zone for the kids. Our kids were happy to bounce back and forth between both areas. Finding chairs in the morning was not a problem on the Freedom. By the afternoon on the Days at Sea the decks were pretty full, but not uncomfortable as they are on DCL ships. Plus there are many more hot tubs for all to share. Clear Advantage: FREEDOM.
STATEROOMS We were in an inside stateroom on the Dream and an outside view room on the Freedom. Each room was fine for our needs and our room stewards were both outstanding.
MISCELANNEOUS One thing we noticed on the Freedom is that there seemed to be more to do at night if you werent going to go to the show. The Royal Promenade always had something going on, there seemed to be lots of things happening on the pool deck, there were many lounges and corners with singing, karaoke, trivia, etc , and of course there is the casino. When we cruise Disney, it seems as if the main event each night is the showwhich as I said we lovebut there doesnt seem to be much more action apart from that. At least its not in the open. And to be honest, Im really OK with that. Were the kind of family that can be very content to walk around the deck after the show then heading in for bed after a long day in the sun. But there was something fun about all the activity happening at night on the Freedom too. I guess thats a TOSS-UP, but something to consider if/when you decide to book.
Again, please know this review was not designed to say one cruise was bad and the other was good. I would sail on both lines again in the future (in fact, were already booked again on two cruises: DCL in 2013 and RCCL in 2014!!!). But hopefully this may help you as you decide whats best for your family.
Let me also say thank you to all who post on the boards. This is truly a wonderful forum and youve made all of our Disney trips so much better because of your input and tips. If you have any questions, I'd be glad to try to answer anything.
Happy Cruising!